Bring_me_that_logo

Brooklyn Pizza - Tallahassee, FL

2035 West Pensacola Street, Tallahassee, FL 32304
FL > Tallahassee > 32304
Pickup
|
Delivery






Popular Items

Cheese

$17.49
Cheesecake

$4.36
Veal Parm

$11.24
Garlic Bread

$2.86
10 Wings

$8.11

Main Menu

Daily Specials

Order Daily Specials food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Daily Specials

Large pizza 1 topping, garlic knots, and 2 liter soda.

$28.88

Pasta Dinner

Order Baked Manicotti food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Baked Manicotti

Baked pasta sleeves stuffed with a ricotta cheese blend topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese served with 3 garlic knots.

$17.88
Order Baked Cheese Ravioli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Baked Cheese Ravioli

Baked pasta shells filled with our ricotta blend & topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese served with 3 garlic knots.

$17.88
Order Baked Jumbo Stuffed Shells food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Baked Jumbo Stuffed Shells

Jumbo pasta shells stuffed with a ricotta cheese blend topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese served with 3 garlic knots.

$17.88

Appetizers

Order Cheese Knots (5 Pieces) food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Cheese Knots (5 Pieces)

$8.25
Order Chicken Fingers with Fries food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Chicken Fingers with Fries

$13.75
Order Mozzarella Sticks food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Mozzarella Sticks

$6.88
Order Pepperoni Rolls (5 Pieces) food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Pepperoni Rolls (5 Pieces)

$9.62
Order Beer-Battered Onion Rings food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Beer-Battered Onion Rings

Beer battered onion rings with a side of onion ring dipping sauce.

$5.50
Order Garlic Bread without the Cheese food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Garlic Bread without the Cheese

$5.50
Order Brooklyn Cheesy Bread food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Brooklyn Cheesy Bread

8 inch roll, garlic butter and mozzarella cheese.

$6.88

Salads & Sides

Order Large Caesar Salad food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Caesar Salad

Served with three garlic knots. Add chicken for an additional charge.

$11.00
Order Large Italian Salad food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Italian Salad

Served with three garlic knots. Add chicken for an additional charge.

$11.00
Order French Fries food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
French Fries

$4.12
Order Pizza Fries food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Pizza Fries

$6.25
Order Meatballs food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Meatballs

$6.25
Order Garlic Knots (5 Pieces) food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Garlic Knots (5 Pieces)

$4.12
Order Small Caesar Salad food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Caesar Salad

Served with 2 garlic knots. Add Chicken for an additional charge.

$8.25
Order Small Italian Salad food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Italian Salad

Served with 2 garlic knots. Add Chicken for an additional charge.

$8.25
Order Side Sauce food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Side Sauce

$0.38

Pizza

Order Extra Large Cheese Pizza food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Extra Large Cheese Pizza

$22.00
Order Large Cheese Pizza food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Cheese Pizza

$19.25
Order Medium Cheese Pizza food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Cheese Pizza

$16.50
Order Small Cheese Pizza food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Cheese Pizza

$13.75

Calzones and Stromboli's

Order Large Calzone food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Calzone

Served with a side of marinara.

$23.38
Order Medium Calzone food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Calzone

Served with a side of marinara.

$20.62
Order Small Calzone food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Calzone

Served with a side of marinara.

$17.88
Order Large Stromboli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Stromboli

Served with a side of marinara.

$23.38
Order Medium Stromboli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Stromboli

Served with a side of marinara.

$20.62
Order Small Stromboli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Stromboli

Served with a side of marinara.

$17.88

Specialty Pizza Large

Order Large BBQ Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large BBQ Chicken

Tangy BBQ chicken.

$23.38
Order Large Buffalo Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Buffalo Chicken

Mild, medium or hot sauce.

$23.38
Order Large Hawaiian food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Hawaiian

Chicken or ham with pineapple.

$23.38
Order Large Meat food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Meat

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, genoa salami & meatballs.

$24.75
Order Large Spinach & Feta food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Spinach & Feta

Spinach, feta cheese, tomato & fresh garlic.

$23.38
Order Large Supreme food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Supreme

$24.75
Order Large Veggie food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large Veggie

Mushrooms, tomatoes, artichokes hearts, broccoli, eggplant & fresh garlic.

$23.38
Order Large White food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large White

Mozzarella, ricotta & fresh garlic.

$22.00
Order Large White with Garlic Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Large White with Garlic Chicken

Mozzarella, ricotta, chicken and fresh garlic.

$23.38
Order Sicilian food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Sicilian

Large size only. Square, thick & crispy crust includes 1 topping free.

$23.38
Order Western BBQ Pizza food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Western BBQ Pizza

Grilled chicken, onion and BBQ sauce.

$24.75
Order Teriyaki Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Teriyaki Chicken

Grilled chicken, onions, mushrooms and teriyaki sauce.

$24.75
Order Mediterranean food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Mediterranean

Grilled chicken, tomato, black olives & feta cheese.

$24.75
Order Philly Steak & Cheese food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Philly Steak & Cheese

Steak, onions & green peppers.

$24.75

Specialty Pizza Medium

Order Medium Hawaiian food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Hawaiian

Chicken or ham with pineapple.

$20.62
Order Medium Meat food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Meat

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, genoa salami, and meatballs.

$22.00
Order Medium Spinach & Feta food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Spinach & Feta

Spinach, feta cheese, tomato, and fresh garlic.

$20.62
Order Medium Supreme food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Supreme

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, mushrooms onions and garlic.

$22.00
Order Medium White food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium White

Mozzarella, ricotta and fresh garlic.

$19.25
Order Medium White with Garlic Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium White with Garlic Chicken

Mozzarella, ricotta, chicken, and fresh garlic.

$20.62
Order Medium BBQ Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium BBQ Chicken

Tangy BBQ chicken.

$20.62
Order Medium Buffalo Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Buffalo Chicken

Mild, medium or hot sauce.

$20.62
Order Medium Veggie food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Medium Veggie

Mushrooms, tomato, artichoke hearts, broccoli, eggplant and fresh garlic.

$20.62

Specialty Pizza Small

Order Small Hawaiian food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Hawaiian

Chicken or ham with pineapple.

$17.88
Order Small Meat food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Meat

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, genoa salami and meatballs.

$19.25
Order Small Spinach & Feta food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Spinach & Feta

Spinach, feta cheese, tomato, and fresh garlic.

$17.88
Order Small Supreme food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Supreme

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, mushrooms onions and garlic.

$19.25
Order Small White food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small White

Mozzarella, ricotta, and fresh garlic.

$16.50
Order Small White with Garlic Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small White with Garlic Chicken

Mozzarella, ricotta, chicken, and fresh garlic.

$17.88
Order Small BBQ Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small BBQ Chicken

Tangy BBQ chicken.

$17.88
Order Small Buffalo Chicken food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Buffalo Chicken

Mild, medium or hot sauce.

$17.88
Order Small Veggie food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Small Veggie

Mushrooms, tomato, artichoke hearts, broccoli, eggplant, and fresh garlic.

$17.88

Specialty Calzones and Strombolis

Order Meat Calzone food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Meat Calzone

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, genoa salami, and meatballs. Served with a side of marinara.

$22.00
Order Meat Stromboli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Meat Stromboli

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, genoa salami, and meatballs. Served with a side of marinara.

$22.00
Order Spinach & Feta Calzone food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Spinach & Feta Calzone

Spinach, feta cheese, tomato garlic and mozzarella cheese served with a side of marinara.

$22.00
Order Spinach & Feta Stromboli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Spinach & Feta Stromboli

Spinach, feta cheese, tomato garlic and mozzarella cheese served with a side of marinara.

$22.00

Toasted Subs & Burgers

Order Classic Cheese Burger and Fries food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Classic Cheese Burger and Fries

$13.75
Order 8" Chicken Parmesan Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Chicken Parmesan Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Chicken Parmesan Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Chicken Parmesan Sub

$13.75
Order 8" Eggplant Parmesan Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Eggplant Parmesan Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Eggplant Parmesan Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Eggplant Parmesan Sub

$13.75
Order 8" Buffalo Chicken Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Buffalo Chicken Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Buffalo Chicken Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Buffalo Chicken Sub

$13.75
Order 8" Meatball Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Meatball Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Meatball Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Meatball Sub

$13.75
Order 8" Philly Steak & Cheese Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Philly Steak & Cheese Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Philly Steak & Cheese Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Philly Steak & Cheese Sub

$13.75
Order 8" Philly Chicken & Cheese Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
8" Philly Chicken & Cheese Sub

$11.00
Order 12" Philly Chicken & Cheese Sub food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
12" Philly Chicken & Cheese Sub

$13.75

Buffalo Wings

Order 10 Wings food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
10 Wings

10 wings.

$19.25
Order 20 Wings food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
20 Wings

20 wings.

$35.75
Order 30 Wings food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
30 Wings

30 Wings.

$53.62
Order 10 Boneless Wings food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
10 Boneless Wings

10 boneless wings.

$13.75

Beverages

Order Ice Tea food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Ice Tea

$3.50
Order 2 - Liter Soda food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
2 - Liter Soda

$4.12
Order Can Soda food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Can Soda

$1.38
Order 20 oz Soda food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
20 oz Soda

$3.50
Order 20 oz Bottled Water food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
20 oz Bottled Water

$3.50

Desserts

Order Cannoli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Cannoli

$6.25
Order Chocolate Covered Cannoli food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Covered Cannoli

$6.25
Order Tiramisu food online from Brooklyn Pizza store, Tallahassee on bringmethat.com
Tiramisu

$6.25

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ