Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy

Sponge candy is Erie's signature candy and it's simply delicious. In other parts of the country, it's also called seafoam, honeycomb or cinder toffee, or hokey pokey. Each bite offers the creamy smoothness of Stefanelli's candies milk chocolate with the melt-away crunch of toffee filling. Try to have just one piece.

Dark Chocolate Sponge Candy

Some people call it seafoam or sponge toffee, but we call it sponge candy and it's simply delicious. Each bite offers the creamy smoothness of Stefanelli's candies dark chocolate with the melt-away crunch of toffee filling. Try to have just one piece.

Milk Chocolate Assortment

A delicious assortment of our finest chocolates. An afternoon pick-me-up or a thoughtful gift available in all the right sizes.

Cherry Cordials

Rich milk chocolate surrounds a luscious cherry center. Each pound of cherry cordials is sold in our classic gift box.

Milk and Dark Assortment

1 or 2 pounds of our delectable assorted milk and dark chocolates.

Nuts And Chewies

Chewy, crunchy, and above all, tasty. Treat yourself to 1 or 2 pounds of our delicious assorted nuts, caramels, and nougats.

Milk Chocolate Nut Assortment

Choose from 1 or 2 pounds of our assorted milk chocolate covered nuts.

Dark Chocolate Assortment

1 pound of our delicious assorted dark chocolates.

Almond Toffee Bark

Assorted Dark Chocolate Nougat

Soft, whipped nougat encased in a dark chocolate shell available in plain or raspberry flavors.

Assorted Jellies

Each of these milk and dark chocolate gems contains a dollop of fruit jelly. Variations include strawberry cheesecake, lemon meringue, raspberry, peanut butter with grape jelly, peanut butter with strawberry jelly and lemon.

Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat

Soft, whipped nougat encased in a milk chocolate shell available in plain, cherry, or raspberry flavors.

Bridge Mix

Snack on an assortment of chocolate-covered nuts, fruits, caramels, and creams. Sold in a 12 oz. Bag.

Chocolate Covered Almonds

Chocolate-covered almonds in delicious milk chocolate. Available in 3oz bag.

Chocolate Covered Cashews

Chocolate-covered cashews in our delicious milk chocolate. Available in 3oz bag.

Chocolate Covered Marshmallows

Light, spongy marshmallows in a chocolate shell. Our chocolate covered marshmallows are sold in bags of three because we know you can't have just one.

Chocolate Covered Potato Chips

Grab a 4 ounce. Bag of our milk chocolate covered potato chips and efficiently feed two cravings at the same time.

Chocolate Covered Rice Krispie Treats

Rice Krispie treat coated in milk chocolate and sold individually.

Dark Chocolate Bark

Dark Chocolate. Snap yourself off a piece of our decadent dark chocolate bark. Plain for the chocolate connoisseur. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

Dark Espresso. Enjoy bold, roasty coffeeshop flavor in a 4-ounce bag. Indulge in our dark chocolate covered espresso beans.

Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Our dark chocolate covered pretzels combine a sweet and salty flavor for a timeless appeal.

Dark Chocolate Nut Bark

You'll go nuts for our sumptuously snappy chocolate bark, available in the following varieties: Dark chocolate — Almond and Mixed. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Raisin Bark

Dark chocolate.

Hodge Podge Clusters

Our hodge-podge clusters roll all your snack favorites into one bite, crushed potato chips, pretzels, and sugar shelled chocolate candies pile together under milk chocolate for a satisfying salty-sweet crunch.

Krispie Bark

Crisped rice infused into sheets of creamy milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Krispie Mallow Bark

Crisped rice cereal and miniature marshmallows immersed in milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Large Chocolate Covered Pretzel

Large milk chocolate covered pretzel with sprinkles, 0.95 ounces.

Milk Chocolate Bark

Milk chocolate flavor. Unadulterated milk chocolate at its finest, with a subtle snap to keep you coming back. Sold per pound.

Milk Chocolate Caramels

Our specialty soft caramels sold by the pound. Varieties include milk chocolate caramel, salted milk chocolate caramel, milk chocolate caramel nut, and milk chocolate salted caramel nut.

Milk Chocolate Covered Animal Crackers

Milk chocolate flavor. Embrace your inner child with crispy animal crackers coated in milk chocolate. Available in the 4ounce package.

Milk Chocolate Covered Brazil Nuts

Milk Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

Milk Espresso. Enjoy bold, roasty coffeeshop flavor in a 4-ounce bag. Indulge in our milk chocolate covered espresso beans.

Milk Chocolate Covered Oreos

America's favorite cookie just got better. Our chocolate covered Oreo cookies are sold by the pair in milk chocolate, dark chocolate, mint Oreos covered in milk chocolate, or mint Oreos dipped in dark chocolate.

Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Our chocolate covered pretzels combine a sweet and salty flavor for timeless appeal.

Milk Chocolate Nut Bark

You'll go nuts for our sumptuously snappy chocolate bark, available in the following varieties: Milk chocolate, walnut, pecan, almond, cashew and mixed. Dark chocolate, almond and mixed. Sold per pound.

Milk Chocolate Raisin Bark

Milk chocolate flavor. Milk chocolate bark surrounds sweet, chewy raisins. Sold per pound.

New York Mix Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

NYX mix flavor. A robust assortment of your favorite coffee shop flavors encases roasted espresso beans for a boost you'll crave.

Peanut Butter Cup Bark

Peanut butter-swirled milk chocolate bark plays host to our craveable chopped peanut butter cups.

Seasoned Bark

A 4ounce bag of blended milk and dark chocolate with a hint of our special seasoning.

Milk Chocolate Melting Caps

Milk chocolate. Utilize our milk chocolate melting caps in your baked goods or homemade confectionery and watch the compliments pour in. Sold in a 16-ounce bag.

White Chocolate Melting Caps

White Chocolate. Utilize our white chocolate melting caps in your baked goods or homemade confectionery and watch the compliments pour in. Sold in a 16-ounce bag.

Milk Chocolate Melt-A-Way

Milk chocolate. Specially crafted for unbelievable melt-in-your-mouth texture, our melt-a-ways are among our most popular items. Choose from plain milk chocolate, peanut butter milk chocolate, raspberry milk chocolate, orange milk chocolate, pecan milk chocolate, coconut milk chocolate, or mint milk chocolate.

Large Mallow Cup

Our gooey marshmallow fluff in a large milk chocolate cup.

Large Peanut Butter Cup

Jumbo homemade peanut butter cup. More than a mouthful of rich, creamy peanut butter to fill you up.

Dark Chocolate Melt-A-Way

Dark chocolate. Specially crafted for unbelievable melt-in-your-mouth texture, our melt-a-ways are among our most popular items. Choose from plain dark chocolate, peanut butter dark chocolate, raspberry dark chocolate, orange dark chocolate, pecan dark chocolate, or mint dark chocolate.

Milk Chocolate Pecan Frogs

Milk Chocolate. Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle, a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with milk chocolate. Sold per pound.

Mini Soft Centered Caramels

Our premium soft-centered caramels, shrunken down for optimum snackability.

Milk Chocolate Miniatures

Milk chocolate. Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk chocolate. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Milk Chocolate Peanut Clusters

These clusters are chock full of peanuts and covered in our smooth melt-in-your-mouth milk chocolate. Peanut clusters sold in 5-ounce bags and available in milk chocolate only.

Nonpareils

Plain milk chocolate discs topped with nonpareils. Available in a 4ounce box.

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Milk chocolate.

Milk Chocolate Almond Toffee Crunch

Our homemade old-fashioned buttery toffee candy with crushed almond offered in milk chocolate. Priced per pound.

Milk Chocolate Peppermint Patties

Smooth, refreshing peppermint cream in a milk chocolate coating. Sold in an 8-ounce box.

Dark Chocolate Peppermint Patties

Smooth, refreshing peppermint cream in a dark chocolate patty. Sold in an 8-ounce box.

Creamy Patty

Malt Balls

Crispy chocolate malted milk balls in milk chocolate coating. Sold in a 4-ounce bag.

Cookie Butter Cups

Cookie butter, shortbread cookie crumbs, butter, flour, and sugar formed into spreadable delight, form the core of our cookie butter cups.

Dark Chocolate Caramels

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Smoothie

Milk chocolate with our signature smooth peanut butter filling. Sold per pound.

Flutter Nutter Candy

This is our new must-try homemade candy. It is a layer of our delicious peanut butter smoothie over top a layer of our gooey homemade marshmallow. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Almond Toffee Crunch

Our homemade old fashioned buttery toffee candy with crushed almond offered in dark chocolate. Priced per pound.

Assorted Milk Chocolate Nougat

Soft, whipped nougat encased in a milk chocolate shell available in plain, cherry, or raspberry flavors.

Rocky Road Sundae Bar

A rocky road sundae on a stick, chopped almonds and marshmallow enveloped in a crunchy chocolate shell.

Mallow Bar

Homemade marshmallow with a touch of vanilla, blanketed in milk chocolate. A true customer favorite. Weights may vary.

Dark Chocolate Pecan Frogs

Frogs are our version of the traditional turtle, a chewy, nutty pecan and caramel patty topped with dark chocolate. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Dark chocolate. Our homemade cups with peanut butter smoothie filling, available in dark chocolate. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Coconut Logs

For the coconut lovers in the bunch. Chewy coconut centers enrobed in creamy dark chocolate. Coconut joy has the added touch of an almond placed on top. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Clusters

Our clusters are chock full of nuts and covered with our smooth dark chocolate. Guaranteed a nut in every bite. Walnut, cashew, coconut, and toasted coconut in dark chocolate. Sold per pound.

Milk Chocolate Coconut Logs

Milk chocolate. For the coconut lovers in the bunch. Chewy coconut centers enrobed in creamy milk chocolate. Coconut joy has the added touch of an almond placed on top. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Smoothie

Dark chocolate with our signature smooth peanut butter filling. Sold per pound.

Dark Chocolate Miniatures

Dark chocolate. Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk, dark, or white chocolate. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Milk Chocolate Clusters

Milk chocolate. Our clusters are chock full of nuts and covered with our smooth milk chocolate. Guaranteed a nut in every bite. Pecan is available in milk chocolate only. Walnut, cashew, and coconut in milk chocolate.

Milk Chocolate Break-Up Bar

Portion control made easy. Our milk chocolate break-up bars break apart into even sections so you can properly pace yourself or not. Sold per pound.

Milk Chocolate Nut Cups

8 ounce. Macadamia, Almond, Peanut, Filbert cups available in milk or dark.

Milk Chocolate Nut Cups

16 ounce. Macadamia, almond, peanut, filbert cups available in milk chocolate.

Dark Chocolate Nut Cups

Macadamia, almond, peanut, filbert cups available in dark chocolate.

Milk Chocolate Bar

Savor Stefanelli's milk chocolate by itself in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. But you'll find that's impossible.

Soft Creamy Caramel Milk Chocolate

Savor Stefanelli's milk chocolate paired with luxuriously creamy caramel. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. But you'll find that's impossible.

Peanut Butter Smoothie Milk Chocolate Bar

Savor Stefanelli's milk chocolate with peanut butter in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. But you'll find that's impossible.

Krispie Milk Chocolate Bar

Savor Stefanelli's milk chocolate paired with Krispies in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. But you'll find that's impossible.

Dark Chocolate Bar

Savor Stefanelli's dark chocolate by itself in our 1.25-ounce bars. This creation is so rich you'll be tempted to set some aside for later. But you'll find that's impossible.

Dark Chocolate Liquor Cups

Dark chocolate. A dark chocolate shot glass. Bottoms up. Weights may vary.

Solid White Chocolate Candy Bar

White chocolate. Solid 3 ounce. White chocolate candy bar, stamped with the Stefanelli's candies insignia.

Solid Milk Chocolate Candy Bar

Solid 3 ounce. Milk chocolate candy bar, stamped with the Stefanelli's candies insignia.

Milk Chocolate Liquor Cups

Milk chocolate. Milk chocolate shot glass. Bottoms up. Weights may vary.

Dark Chocolate Minitures

Dark chocolate. Assorted solid chocolate miniature shapes in milk, dark, or white chocolate. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Peanut Brittle

Stefanelli's homemade peanut brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted peanuts in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Cashew Brittle

Stefanelli's homemade cashew brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted cashews in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Cashew Brittle

Stefanelli's homemade cashew brittle is a crispy, crunchy candy loaded with roasted cashews in a buttery, sweet candy coating. Available in a 4-ounce bag.

Buttermints

Old-fashioned, buttery, sweet, minty candy - our buttermints are available in an 8-ounce bag.

Licorice Mix

With a variety of assorted licorice pieces, this bag of licorice allsorts is the perfect confection for any licorice lover. Available in a 6-ounce bag.

Sour Brite Gummy Worms

Stefanelli's deliciously sour gummy worms will wake up your taste buds. Enjoy a 12-ounce bag of sour gummy worms.

Gummy Bears

Our small, fruit-flavored gummy bears are soft and sweet. Enjoy a 12-ounce bag of our gummy bears.

Gummy Worms

Our fruit-flavored gummy worms are soft and sweet. Enjoy a 12-ounce bag of our gummy worms.