Bring_me_that_logo

Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs

1506 Old Butler Rd, New Castle, PA 16101
PA > New Castle > 16101
Pickup
|
Delivery

Main Menu

Pizza

Order Cheese Pizza - 7" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 7"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$3.88
Order Cheese Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 12"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$11.00
Order Cheese Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 14"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$15.12
Order Cheese Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 16"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$16.50

Specialty Pizza

Order Deluxe Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Deluxe Pizza - 12"

Pepperoni,sausage, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$16.50
Order Deluxe Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Deluxe Pizza - 14"

Pepperoni,sausage, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$20.62
Order Deluxe Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Deluxe Pizza - 16"

Pepperoni,sausage, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.

$22.00
Order Veggie Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Veggie Pizza - 12"

Broccoli, cauliflower, special sauces & 2 kinds of cheese.

$16.50
Order Veggie Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Veggie Pizza - 14"

Broccoli, cauliflower, special sauces & 2 kinds of cheese.

$20.62
Order Veggie Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Veggie Pizza - 16"

Broccoli, cauliflower, special sauces & 2 kinds of cheese.

$22.00
Order Poor Man's White Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Poor Man's White Pizza - 12"

Cheese, hot peppers, oil, garlic & tomatoes.

$12.38
Order Poor Man's White Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Poor Man's White Pizza - 14"

Cheese, hot peppers, oil, garlic & tomatoes.

$17.88
Order Poor Man's White Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Poor Man's White Pizza - 16"

Cheese, hot peppers, oil, garlic & tomatoes.

$19.25
Order Homestyle Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Homestyle Pizza - 12"

Sauce, parm cheese & seasonings.

$13.75
Order Homestyle Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Homestyle Pizza - 14"

Sauce, parm cheese & seasonings.

$16.50
Order Homestyle Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Homestyle Pizza - 16"

Sauce, parm cheese & seasonings.

$19.25
Order Chilli Dog Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chilli Dog Pizza - 12"

Chilli sauce, hot dogs, onions & cheddar cheese.

$16.50
Order Chilli Dog Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chilli Dog Pizza - 14"

Chilli sauce, hot dogs, onions & cheddar cheese.

$20.62
Order Chilli Dog Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chilli Dog Pizza - 16"

Chilli sauce, hot dogs, onions & cheddar cheese.

$22.00
Order Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 12"

$16.50
Order Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 14"

$20.62
Order Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Bacon Triple Cheese Pizza - 16"

$22.00
Order Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 12"

$16.50
Order Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 14"

$20.62
Order Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza - 16"

$22.00
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 12"

$16.50
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 14"

$20.62
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16"

$22.00
Order Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 12"

$16.50
Order Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 14"

$20.62
Order Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 16"

$22.00
Order Meat Lovers Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Meat Lovers Pizza - 12"

$16.50
Order Meat Lovers Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Meat Lovers Pizza - 14"

$20.62
Order Meat Lovers Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Meat Lovers Pizza - 16"

$22.00
Order Philly Steak Pizza - 12" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Philly Steak Pizza - 12"

Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, & special sauce.

$16.50
Order Philly Steak Pizza - 14" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Philly Steak Pizza - 14"

Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, & special sauce.

$20.62
Order Philly Steak Pizza - 16" food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Philly Steak Pizza - 16"

Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, & special sauce.

$22.00

Pizza Rolls

Order Ham & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Ham & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular

$8.25
Order Steak & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Steak & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular

$8.25
Order Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza Roll - Regular

$8.25

Sticks

Order Cheese Sticks - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Sticks - Appetizer

A great tasting blend of four star fresh dough, real mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce.

$6.88
Order Bread Sticks - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Bread Sticks - Appetizer

Delicious fresh baked includes the sauce.

$5.50
Order Cinna Sticks with Icing - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cinna Sticks with Icing - Appetizer

$5.50
Order French Fries - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
French Fries - Appetizer

$3.50
Order Chili - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chili - Appetizer

$1.75
Order Cheese - Appetizer food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese - Appetizer

$1.12

Salads

Order Garden Salad - Small food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Garden Salad - Small

$4.12
Order Garden Salad - Large food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Garden Salad - Large

$6.88
Order Chicken Salad - Small food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad - Small

$6.25
Order Chicken Salad - Large food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad - Large

$9.00
Order Chef Salad - Small food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chef Salad - Small

$4.88
Order Chef Salad - Large food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chef Salad - Large

$7.62
Order Steak Salad - Small food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Steak Salad - Small

$6.25
Order Steak Salad - Large food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Steak Salad - Large

$9.00

Stromboli

Order Ham Stromboli - Stromboli food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Ham Stromboli - Stromboli

$11.00
Order Steak Stromboli - Stromboli food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Steak Stromboli - Stromboli

Includes cheese, onions, green peppers, special sauce.

$11.00
Order Meatball Stromboli - Stromboli food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Meatball Stromboli - Stromboli

Includes sauce & cheese.

$11.00
Order Deluxe Stromboli - Stromboli food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Deluxe Stromboli - Stromboli

Includes pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, hot peppers & cheese.

$11.00

Subs

Order Italian Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Italian Sub - 12" Sub

Capicola, salami, cheese.

$9.62
Order Cheese Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Cheese Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Ham & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Ham & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Meatball & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Meatball & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Turkey & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Turkey & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Pepperoni & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Pepperoni & Cheese Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Veggie Steak Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Veggie Steak Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Sausage Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Sausage Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order BLT Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
BLT Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Chicken Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62
Order Chicken Parm Sub - 12" Sub food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Parm Sub - 12" Sub

$9.62

Wings

Order Chicken Wings - 12 Pieces food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Wings - 12 Pieces

$13.75
Order Chicken Wings - 24 Pieces food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Wings - 24 Pieces

$26.12
Order Chicken Wings - 50 Pieces food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Chicken Wings - 50 Pieces

$49.50

Drinks

Order Coca Cola Classic - 20 Oz food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Coca Cola Classic - 20 Oz

$2.38
Order Coca Cola Classic - 2 Liter food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Coca Cola Classic - 2 Liter

$3.50
Order Sprite - 20 Oz food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Sprite - 20 Oz

$2.38
Order Sprite - 2 Liter food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Sprite - 2 Liter

$3.50
Order Diet Coke - 20 Oz food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Diet Coke - 20 Oz

$2.38
Order Diet Coke - 2 Liter food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Diet Coke - 2 Liter

$3.50
Order Root Beer - 20 Oz food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Root Beer - 20 Oz

$2.38
Order Root Beer - 2 Liter food online from Fourstar Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs store, New Castle on bringmethat.com
Root Beer - 2 Liter

$3.50

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2024 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ