Bring_me_that_logo

Old Time Pizza

19152 County Rd 46, New Paris, IN 46553
IN > New Paris > 46553
Pickup
|
Delivery

Main Menu

Pizza

Order Cheese Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 7"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$3.78
Order Cheese Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 10"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$6.81
Order Cheese Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 12"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$8.88
Order Cheese Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 14"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$11.19
Order Cheese Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza - 16"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$13.25
Order Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 7"

$4.96
Order Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 10"

$8.21
Order Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 12"

$10.40
Order Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 14"

$12.91
Order Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with One Topping - 16"

$15.16
Order Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 7"

$6.15
Order Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 10"

$9.60
Order Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 12"

$11.92
Order Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 14"

$14.64
Order Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Two Toppings - 16"

$17.09
Order Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 7"

$7.35
Order Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 10"

$10.99
Order Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 12"

$13.44
Order Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 14"

$16.36
Order Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Three Toppings - 16"

$19.01
Order Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 7"

$8.54
Order Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 10"

$12.39
Order Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 12"

$14.96
Order Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 14"

$18.08
Order Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Four Toppings - 16"

$20.92
Order Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 7"

$9.74
Order Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 10"

$13.78
Order Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 12"

$16.49
Order Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 14"

$19.80
Order Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Five Toppings - 16"

$22.85
Order Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 7"

$10.92
Order Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 10"

$15.16
Order Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 12"

$18.01
Order Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 14"

$21.52
Order Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheese Pizza with Six Toppings - 16"

$24.78
Order Supreme Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Supreme Pizza - 7"

$12.11
Order Supreme Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Supreme Pizza - 10"

$16.56
Order Supreme Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Supreme Pizza - 12"

$19.54
Order Supreme Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Supreme Pizza - 14"

$23.25
Order Supreme Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Supreme Pizza - 16"

$26.69
Order Double Supreme Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Double Supreme Pizza - 12"

$29.81
Order Double Supreme Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Double Supreme Pizza - 14"

$34.64
Order Double Supreme Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Double Supreme Pizza - 16"

$38.35

Special Pizzas

Order Hawaiian Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hawaiian Pizza - 7"

Ham, green pepper, onion & pineapple.

$8.88
Order Hawaiian Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hawaiian Pizza - 10"

Ham, green pepper, onion & pineapple.

$12.71
Order Hawaiian Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hawaiian Pizza - 12"

Ham, green pepper, onion & pineapple.

$15.30
Order Hawaiian Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hawaiian Pizza - 14"

Ham, green pepper, onion & pineapple.

$18.41
Order Hawaiian Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hawaiian Pizza - 16"

Ham, green pepper, onion & pineapple.

$21.26
Order Cheeseburger Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Pizza - 7"

Hamburger, cheddar & mozzarella.

$7.35
Order Cheeseburger Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Pizza - 10"

Hamburger, cheddar & mozzarella.

$10.99
Order Cheeseburger Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Pizza - 12"

Hamburger, cheddar & mozzarella.

$13.44
Order Cheeseburger Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Pizza - 14"

Hamburger, cheddar & mozzarella.

$16.36
Order Cheeseburger Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Pizza - 16"

Hamburger, cheddar & mozzarella.

$19.01
Order Baconburger Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Baconburger Pizza - 7"

Cheeseburger plus bacon

$8.68
Order Baconburger Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Baconburger Pizza - 10"

Cheeseburger plus bacon

$13.51
Order Baconburger Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Baconburger Pizza - 12"

Cheeseburger plus bacon

$15.16
Order Baconburger Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Baconburger Pizza - 14"

Cheeseburger plus bacon

$18.21
Order Baconburger Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Baconburger Pizza - 16"

Cheeseburger plus bacon

$21.32
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 7"

BBQ sauce, chicken & bacon.

$8.94
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 10"

BBQ sauce, chicken & bacon.

$13.78
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 12"

BBQ sauce, chicken & bacon.

$15.42
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 14"

BBQ sauce, chicken & bacon.

$18.48
Order BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16"

BBQ sauce, chicken & bacon.

$21.59
Order Chicken Club Pizza - 7" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Pizza - 7"

Ranch or mayonnaise, chicken & bacon.

$8.94
Order Chicken Club Pizza - 10" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Pizza - 10"

Ranch or mayonnaise, chicken & bacon.

$13.78
Order Chicken Club Pizza - 12" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Pizza - 12"

Ranch or mayonnaise, chicken & bacon.

$15.42
Order Chicken Club Pizza - 14" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Pizza - 14"

Ranch or mayonnaise, chicken & bacon.

$18.48
Order Chicken Club Pizza - 16" food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Pizza - 16"

Ranch or mayonnaise, chicken & bacon.

$21.59

Salads

Order Applesauce - Salad food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Applesauce - Salad

$1.56
Order Coleslaw Salad - Single food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Coleslaw Salad - Single

$1.56
Order Coleslaw Salad - Pint food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Coleslaw Salad - Pint

$4.88
Order Tossed Salad - Salad food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Tossed Salad - Salad

$3.54
Order Chicken Salad - Salad food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad - Salad

$5.31
Order Chef Salad - Small food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chef Salad - Small

$5.31
Order Chef Salad - Large food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chef Salad - Large

$6.56
Order Taco Salad - Small food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Taco Salad - Small

$5.62
Order Taco Salad - Large food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Taco Salad - Large

$6.88
Order Grilled Chicken Salad - Small food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Grilled Chicken Salad - Small

$6.88
Order Grilled Chicken Salad - Large food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Grilled Chicken Salad - Large

$8.12

Sides

Order Nachos & Cheese - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Nachos & Cheese - Side

$5.01
Order Bread Sticks - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Bread Sticks - Side

With sauce or cheese.

$4.38
Order Garlic Bread - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Garlic Bread - Side

$4.38
Order Cross Cut Fries - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Cross Cut Fries - Side

$5.22
Order Mini Tacos - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Mini Tacos - Side

$7.29
Order Mojos - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Mojos - Side

$4.50
Order Ice Cream - Per dip food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Ice Cream - Per dip

$1.19
Order Mini Corn Dogs - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Mini Corn Dogs - Side

$6.62
Order Mozzarella Sticks - Side food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Mozzarella Sticks - Side

$6.62

Dinners

Order Spaghetti - Half food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Spaghetti - Half

Served with garlic bread.

$5.96
Order Spaghetti - Full food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Spaghetti - Full

Served with garlic bread.

$9.94
Order Wet Burrito - Dinner food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Wet Burrito - Dinner

Soft tortilla, ground beef, refried beans, enchilada sauce, cheddar cheese, lettuce, sour cream.

$8.69
Order Broasted Pork Chop - 1 Piece food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Broasted Pork Chop - 1 Piece

Pork chop, mojos, applesauce.

$12.19
Order Broasted Pork Chop - 2 Pieces food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Broasted Pork Chop - 2 Pieces

Pork chop, mojos, applesauce.

$17.50
Order Chicken Dinner - Dinner food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Dinner - Dinner

3 Pieces chicken, mojos, and cole slaw.

$10.81
Order Chicken Snack Pack - Dinner food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Snack Pack - Dinner

3 Pieces of chicken, mojos, and coleslaw.

$9.50
Order Chicken Tenders - Dinner food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Tenders - Dinner

3 Pieces of chicken tenderloin, and fries.

$8.61

Sandwiches

Order Super Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Super Sandwich - Sandwich

Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, ham onions, mushrooms, green peppers, green olives, black olives, mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven.

$8.28
Order Gyro Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Gyro Sandwich - Sandwich

Pita bread, gyro meat, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, tzatziki-cucumber sauce.

$8.28
Order Hilly Billy Hot Dog Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hilly Billy Hot Dog Sandwich - Sandwich

Chili, coleslaw, cheddar cheese, and onions.

$7.38
Order Video Sub Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Video Sub Sandwich - Sandwich

Sliced ham, pepproni, salami, mozzarella cheese, pizza sauce, baked in oven.

$7.61
Order Submarine Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Submarine Sandwich - Sandwich

Sliced ham, pepperoni, slami, mozzarella cheese, pizza sauce, baked in oven.

$7.95
Order BBQ Chicken Sub Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
BBQ Chicken Sub Sandwich - Sandwich

BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon and mozzarella cheese.

$7.95
Order Chicken Club Sub Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Club Sub Sandwich - Sandwich

Served with ranch dressing or mayo, chicken, bacon and mozzarella cheese.

$7.95
Order Roast Beef Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Roast Beef Sandwich - Sandwich

Hoagie bun, pizza sauce, roast beef, mozzarella cheese, lettuce Italian dressing, baked in the oven.

$7.29
Order Super Sausage Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Super Sausage Sandwich - Sandwich

Pizza sauce, smoked sausage, mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven.

$7.08
Order Ham & Cheese Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Ham & Cheese Sandwich - Sandwich

Thin slices of ham topped with mozzarella cheese and baked in the oven.

$6.75
Order Stromboli - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Stromboli - Sandwich

Ground sausage served on a bun with pizza sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven.

$6.75
Order Grilled Chicken Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Grilled Chicken Sandwich - Sandwich

Skinless chicken breast fillet, baked in the oven with choice of condiments.

$6.75
Order Chicken Salad Sandwich - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad Sandwich - Sandwich

$6.11
Order Hot Dog - Sandwich food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Hot Dog - Sandwich

Served with choice of condiments.

$3.56

Chicken

Order Chicken - 8 Pieces food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken - 8 Pieces

$23.49
Order Chicken - 12 Pieces food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken - 12 Pieces

$32.95
Order Chicken - 16 Pieces food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Chicken - 16 Pieces

$41.20
Order Single Piece of Chicken Breast - Chicken food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Single Piece of Chicken Breast - Chicken

$5.01
Order Single Piece of Chicken Wing - Chicken food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Single Piece of Chicken Wing - Chicken

$2.50
Order Single Piece of Chicken Thigh - Chicken food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Single Piece of Chicken Thigh - Chicken

$3.69
Order Single Piece of Chicken Leg - Chicken food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Single Piece of Chicken Leg - Chicken

$2.50
Order Single Piece of Pork Chop - Chicken food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Single Piece of Pork Chop - Chicken

$7.62

Beverages

Order Fountain Drink - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Fountain Drink - Beverage

$2.50
Order Canned Pop - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Canned Pop - Beverage

$1.19
Order 2 Liter Pop - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
2 Liter Pop - Beverage

$3.12
Order Pitcher - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Pitcher - Beverage

$6.25
Order Coffe - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Coffe - Beverage

$1.56
Order Iced Tea - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
Iced Tea - Beverage

$2.50
Order 12 Pack of Pop - Beverage food online from Old Time Pizza store, New Paris on bringmethat.com
12 Pack of Pop - Beverage

$11.25

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2024 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ