Bring_me_that_logo

Old Cup Cafe - Jacksonville, FL

3604 Saint Johns Avenue, Jacksonville, FL 32205
FL > Jacksonville > 32205
Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Sandwiches Menu

Order Cuban-Ish food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Cuban-Ish

Swiss and Havarti cheese, roasted pulled pork, stone-ground mustard, hot-house pickles, and c and v chips.

$11.75

Bagels & Schmears

Order Bagels food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Bagels

$5.25
Order Cheddar Quiche food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Cheddar Quiche

$9.62
Order Peppers Quiche food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Peppers Quiche

$9.62
Order Schmears food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Schmears

Butter plain vs spicy: sriracha sauce, pepper jelly, cream cheese.

$0.75
Order Tomato Quiche food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Tomato Quiche

$9.62

Muffins

Order Blueberry Muffins food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Blueberry Muffins

$4.12
Order Glorious Morning Muffins food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Glorious Morning Muffins

Dairy-free.

$4.12
Order Banana & Nut Muffins food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Banana & Nut Muffins

$4.12

Cookies

Order Brownie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Brownie

$4.50
Order Lemon Shortbread food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Lemon Shortbread

$4.12
Order Praline Pecan Shortbread food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Praline Pecan Shortbread

$4.88
Order Snickerdoodles Cookie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Snickerdoodles Cookie

$2.50
Order Chocolate Meringue food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Meringue

Gluten-free, dairy-free.

$2.75
Order Oatmeal Raisin Cookie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

$2.50
Order Raspberry Shortbread food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Raspberry Shortbread

$4.12
Order Nutter Butter Sandwich food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Nutter Butter Sandwich

$4.88
Order Nut Brownie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Nut Brownie

$4.88
Order Cowboy Cookie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Cowboy Cookie

$2.50

Pies

Order Coconut Cream Pie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Coconut Cream Pie

$9.62
Order Banana Cream Pie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Banana Cream Pie

$9.62
Order Lemon Meringue Mini Pie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Lemon Meringue Mini Pie

$9.62
Order Cherry Pie food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Cherry Pie

$9.62

Mini Cakes

Order Chocolate Flourless Mini Cake food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Flourless Mini Cake

Gluten-free.

$9.62

Sliced Cakes

Order Cappuccino Cake (1 Slice) food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Cappuccino Cake (1 Slice)

$9.62

Classic Cupcakes

Order Carrot Cupcakes food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Carrot Cupcakes

$5.25
Order Vanilla Buttercream food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Vanilla Buttercream

$2.50
Order Vanilla Chocolate Fudge food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Vanilla Chocolate Fudge

$2.50
Order Chocolate Ganache food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Ganache

$2.50
Order Red Velvet Cupcakes food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Red Velvet Cupcakes

$2.50

Featured Cupcakes

Order Seasonal food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Seasonal

$2.50
Order Chocolate Mousse food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Mousse

$2.50
Order German Chocolate food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
German Chocolate

$2.50
Order Coconut food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Coconut

$2.50
Order Strawberry Mousse food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Strawberry Mousse

$2.50
Order Lemon Mousse food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Lemon Mousse

$5.25
Order Fat Elvis food online from Old Cup Cafe store, Jacksonville on bringmethat.com
Fat Elvis

$2.50

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ