Gaylacake Bakery - Evansville, IN

Regular cupcakes may include any of the following flavors with vanilla icing (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): white, chocolate, strawberry, red velvet, yellow, banana, lemon, orange, confetti.

Specialty cupcakes may include any of the following flavors/icing combos (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): strawberry with cream cheese, red velvet w/ cream cheese, yellow w/ chocolate, banana w/ cream cheese, cookies n cream, chocolate mint, chocolate w/ peanut butter, pumpkin w/ cream cheese, cherry vanilla, and more!

Gourmet flavors may include (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): German chocolate, carrot, coconut, buckeye, lemon supreme, death by chocolate, unicorn, vanilla caramel, caramel macchiato, mocha, raspberry cheesecake, blueberry lemon cheesecake, raspberry lemon, and many more!

12 regular cupcakes may include any of the following flavors with vanilla icing (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): white, chocolate, strawberry, red velvet, yellow, banana, lemon, orange, confetti

12 specialty cupcakes may include any of the following flavors/icing combos (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): strawberry w/ cream cheese, red velvet w/ cream cheese, yellow w/ chocolate, banana w/ cream cheese, cookies n cream, chocolate mint, chocolate w/ peanut butter, pumpkin w/ cream cheese, cherry vanilla, and more!

12 gourmet flavors may include (Variety based upon availability; No special requests): German chocolate, carrot, coconut, buckeye, lemon supreme, death by chocolate, unicorn, vanilla caramel, caramel macchiato, mocha, raspberry cheesecake, blueberry lemon cheesecake, raspberry lemon, and many more!

Build your own cupcake with our Cupcake Bar. Pick your cake flavor, filling, icing, and up to 2 toppings!

12 homestyle cookies can include any of the following flavors (Variety based upon availability: if a flavor is unavailable, a substitution will be made.)

Also known as chess pie bars, these rich delicious treats are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. They have a buttery, cakey crust with a gooey cream cheese filling on top.

A shortbread crust with a pecan pie filling baked over the top.

A chocolaty brownie covered in buckeye (peanut butter) filling covered in rich chocolate ganache.

Golden crispy puff pastry filled with a traditional cream horn fluff, and sprinkled with powdered sugar.

Let our employees take care of your sweet tooth! We will pick out our favorite items from the case and put a variety goody box together within your budget! Some items may include, brownies, bars, cake balls, or cookies! All variety boxes vary depending on items available. If you would like something specific, please let us know in the instructions and we will try to accommodate if possible.

Standard cup of coffee.