Matanzas Inn Restaurant

414 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Saturday's hours: 11:00am - 10:00pm (Hours of Service May Vary)
Nellie's Signature Shrimp Cocktail

Six plump, chilled pearls of the deep. Served with our cocktail sauce and lemon

$12.95
Tavern Bread

A house favorite! A mix of bleu and other tasty melted cheeses, roasted garlic, fresh tomato and more will set your course

$10.95
Coconut Fried Shrimp

Our lightly fried "Famous recipe". Sweet Thai sauce for the dipper

$13.95
Blackened Shrimp and Grouper Bites

Spiced and seared. Served with our fabulous Lobster sherry sauce

$14.95
Shrimp and Scallops Bruschetta

Jumbo shrimp and sea scallops, fresh basil, garlic and ripe tomato in our tasty recipe! Served up with homemade french baguette

$13.95
Florida Gator Bites

Spicy marinated Gator tail fried golden brown. Drizzled with our "almost famous" Pineapple Mango Sauce

$13.95
Fried Green Tomato Stack

Southern favorite, lightly pan fried, finished with goat cheese, roasted red bell peppers and remoulade sauce

$11.95
Homemade Mozzarella Planks

Lightly fried - Amazing! Zesty marinara for the dipper

$9.95
Drunken Wings

A pound of luscious crispy fried wings, tossed in our home-brewed pepper sauce. Hot, Mild, or garlic teriyaki

$8.95
Crabmeat Stuffed Artichoke Dip

Tell the Tale of the Crispy Dipper!! Great to share

$12.95
Crusty Fried Artichokes

Marinated hearts lightly battered and fried - Sided with a dipp'in sauce

$9.95
Buffalo Chicken Salad

Served over mixed baby greens, crisp romaine, seasonal fresh fruit and bleu cheese crumbles with choice of dressing

$12.95
Oh Baby Greens!!

My favorite! Crisp Field Greens, grape tomatoes, fresh berries and more!!

$7.95
Crazy Cobb Salad

A real masterpiece - tender Chicken breast over mixed baby greens, hard boiled egg, crisp bacon, ripe tomato and more

$14.95
Ultimate Chilled Lobster Salad

Maybe our signature salad? But certainly a sincere consideration!! You make the call. Enjoy

$19.95
Crazy Calamari 'N Shrimp

Lightly fried sporting banana peppers, pickled jalapenos, and red cherry peppers - drizzled with balsamic reduction

$12.95
Seafood Quesadilla

Blessed with plump shrimp, scallops, fresh catch and crabmeat- Make this a perfect partner to sweet peppers, onions and melted cheeses

$15.95
Zesty Thai Shrimp Salad

Crispy, spicy shrimp over mixed greens, bell peppers, mushrooms, sprouts and fresh fruit

$13.95
The Wacky Wedge Salad

Ice cold iceberg lettuce wedge with bleu cheese crumbles, diced onion, carrots, vine ripe tomato, crisp smoke bacon, garlic croutons and bleu cheese dressing

$11.95
Pan Tossed Shrimp 'N Scallop Salad

Enjoy jumbo scallops pan seared and topped with our citrus vinaigrette! Mixed greens and seasonal fruit set the tone

$16.95
Pineapple Chicken Salad

Our fabulous recipe - Chicken salad nestled over mixed greens, grazed nuts, red onion, seasonal fruit!

$13.95
Already Famous Calamari

Lightly fried in our olde-time recipe! Fresh lemon and dip for the Dipper!

$10.95
Florida Summer Salad

Crisp field greens, romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed about with sundried cranberries, crisp apple, praline pecans, vine ripe tomato and cukes - Sides with seasonal fruit. We love it

$10.95
Nellie's Inspired Chef Salad

Imagine crisp Lettuce, Smokehouse Bacon, Turkey breast, Roast beef, select cheeses, hard boiled eggs, cukes, Bleu cheese crumbles, fresh seasonal fruit and more!!!

$13.95
Steam'in Mussels

Marinara or Garlic Wine A savory brew! One of our most popular starters.

$12.95
Devilish mussels

Fresh mussels simmered in our zesty sauce. Served up with bread for the dipper!!

$12.95
Rockies

Baked oysters Rockefeller - spinach, bacon, sweet onion, pernod and savory swiss

$12.95
World's Largest Shrimp and Maine Cocktail

Most folks share this one. A full pound of lightly Steamed and Chilled Plump Shrimp, a quarter pound of Maine Lobster meat, lemon wedge, cocktail sauce and melted butter

$27.95
World's Ultimate Lobster Roll

This is the real deal!! The largest you have ever seen - homebaked hoagie roll overloaded with the tastiest, most succulent lobster you can imagine. Sided with plank fries and fresh seasonal fruit

-
Oyster On A Half Shell

Freshly shucked

$9.95
Peel & Eat Chilled Shrimp

Served up with all the fix'ins

$12.95
Seize the Day!!!

Whatever they allow us to brew! Always a wonderful surprise

$6.95
Steam'in Onion Soup Au Gratin

This Ole time favorite crowned with savory garlic toast and melted cheese! Oh yeah

$6.95
Chowder of the day

A generous crock of tasty and hearty brew, filled with good home tradition

$7.95
Plain our way!

$9.95
Pan-Seared Ahi Tuna

$17.95
Chilled Shrimp

$14.95
Lobster Salad

$19.95
Citrus Flame-seared Chicken Breast

$12.95
Grilled Salmon

$15.95
Grab Your Grouper Sandwich

"Claimed to be the World's largest." On a home-baked roll Your way...Fried, Bronzed or Skillet Seared

$18.95
Fresh Haddock Sandwiches Your Way

Choose lightly fried ale butter, bronzed, skillet blackened, pan seared, or crunchy style on a home baked roll crisp lettuce, ripe tomato and more

$13.95
Frenchy's Dip

Sliced roasted beef, piled high on a home-baked hoagie, smothered with savory melted cheese...Tasty broth for the dipper

$13.95
The "Finest Kind" Cheese Steak

Home-baked hoagie over-stuffed with sliced ribeye, sweet onion, mushrooms and bell peppers. Topped with savory melted cheese! Wow

$13.95
Our Favorite Cuban Sandwich

Sourdough hoagie loaded with roasted Cuban pork, swiss cheese, sweet honey ham, pickle and our own special dressing skillet-pressed to a golden brown!! Sided with Black beans and rice

$12.95
Our Own BLT

Crisp Applewood Smoked Bacon, layered tastefully with ripe tomato, sliced cucumbers, hard boiled egg, Swiss cheese and crisp Romaine lettuce on toasted Vienna white!! Mayo on the side

$12.95
The "Big" Sandwich

Dagwood's twisted triple decker shows off succulent roast beef, turkey breast, Applewood smoked bacon, cheeses, tomato, cukes, lettuce and more

$13.95
Old fashioned Chicken Salad Sandwich

Tender white meat chicken, sweet mayo, seasoned to perfection and served an our freshly made bakery bread, romaine and ripe tomato

$11.95
Famous Crunchy Fish Tacos

That's right!! Bring them on - Give em a try and you'll see why!!!

$13.95
Mahi Mahi Soft Tacos

Topped with tropical salsa! Sided with Island black beans and rice

$13.95
Fire-Seared Whiskey Chicken Sandwich

Oh yeah! Basted, then open-flame-seared to perfection, this plump chicken breast, Applewood smoked bacon, grilled Pineapple and cheese will bring you back for more! Enjoy

$11.95
Beach Chicken Sandwich

Lightly fried chicken breast, salsa, jalapeno, bacon, and melted cheese Are you kidding me? On a homebaked kaiser

$12.95
Boom Boom Fried Chicken Sandwich

Country fried chicken breast, smoked bacon, melted provolone cheese and Boom Boom sauce-crisp lettuce & tomato

$12.95
Oh Mahi Mahi Sandwich

Florida key's fresh catch prepared to your liking! Bronzed, Pan Seared, Country fried or skillet blackened - topped with crisp lettuce, onion and ripe tomato

$16.95
Famous Tavern Baby Back Ribs

These ribs are so good, they're bad! baked low and slow! Served with our famous hickory smoked sauce, Home baked beans, and our famous plank French Fries. Try Nellie's Slab for twice the fun!

$16.95
Sweet Caroline's Baby Backs

Falling off the bone delicious! Served with our down south Carolina BBQ sauce, smoky baked beans, and Plank fries. The Joker says, "try batman's Slab"

$16.95
Spicy Bourbon Baby Backs

Are you ready? falling off the bone baby backs. Sauced with a hint of heat and a blast of Jim Beans! Smoky baked beans and Planks fries for company. Double down with the vegas Slab!

$16.95
Hi Country Combo

try this for size! Our slow cooked 1/2 rack BBQ baby back ribs and BBQ pulled pork combo-with all the trimming

$21.95
Wombo Combo

Picture "BBQ Heaven." Our Baby back ribs, BBQ Chicken breast and large Shrimp and Scallops all in one place!! A big ole feast with all the trimmings. My My!!

$27.95
BBQ Pulled Pork Open-Faced

Tender pork pulled and tasty. Piled high atop garlic herb toast Wow

$12.95
Tricky Turkey

Tasty Turkey breast, Applewood smoked bacon, Pineapple, Sweet Onion and melted cheeses..Oh Wow!

$11.95
BBQ Pulled Pork

Only the best in this one! Blessed with sweet onions, and melted American cheese

$11.95
Crabcake Melt

Skillet seared crabcake, Applewood bacon, ripe tomato, American cheese, and tasty Remoulade sauce on grilled Vienna white

$14.95
Grilled Vegetable

Eggplant, Zucchini, Bell Peppers, Artichoke hearts, Onions, Roasted Garlic and Goat cheese - Say no more!

$9.95
A Stav'in Panini

Balsamic grilled chicken, Roma tomato, basil and fresh mozzarella. Grilled on home-baked hoagie

$11.95
Two-Fisted Corned Beef Reuben

Slow roasted corned beef smothered with tangy sauerkraut, dressing and melted Swiss - Sail on!!

$13.95
Oh! Turkey

Turkey breast stacked high with sweet slaw, dressing and melted cheese. Grilled to perfection

$11.95
Harbor Reuben

Crunchy fish, sweet slaw, Melted Provolone, and dressing to boot!!

$12.95
Most interesting Reuben in the World

Tender crispy fried maine lobster meat, sweet cole slaw, thousand island dressing, melted Swiss all grilled on sourdough rye

$19.95
Bronzed Grouper Reuben

Florida catch! Grilled Pineapple, melted swiss, sweet slaw and more!

$18.95
Ridiculous Reuben

Slow roasted corned beef, seasoned pork, savory swiss, Thousand Island dressing and sweet cole slaw - Wow!

$14.95
Plump Shrimp

$13.95
Crispy Scallops

$13.95
Rolled Oysters

$13.95
The San Carlos Slammer

The House Specialty. A Generous half pound burger with American cheese, crispy smoked bacon, golden onion string, tomato and our Special, (If we gave you recipe, we'd have to kill you) Sauce

$13.95
Whiskey Creek BBQ Cheeseburger

A big half pound burger with our hickory BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, smoky bacon, & golden onion strings

$13.95
Santa Fe Blaze Burger

Our half pound burger, with pepper jack cheese, smoky bacon, fried jalapeno and onion strings

$13.95
Ultimate Patty Melt

A full half pound burger, with grilled onions, American and swiss cheese, Thousands Is. Dressings, nestled between our famous home-baked grilled rye. Wow!

$12.95
Sonoma Country Swiss burger

A full half pound burger with mellow swiss cheese and our wine sauteed mushroom medley

$12.95
The "Philly"

Our half pound burger with Provolone cheese, sauteed sweet onions, peppers, and sautted mushrooms

$12.95
Dreamful Cheeseburger

A full half pound, fresh ground, Your choice of american,Swiss,Provolone, or pepper Jack

$11.95
Crunchy Fried Grouper

This is the real deal! a full half pound of grouper, golden brown and fried to prefection! plus two side of your choice

$23.95
Our Sailor's Delight

Jumbo Shrimp, gigantic sea scallops and our incredible maine lobster sauce over pan seared Atlantic Haddock. Dance on Sailor! Plus two sides of your choice

$20.95
Beachbake

Baked Haddock overstuffed with crab meat and crowned with jumbo shrimp, seasoned bread crumbs, roasted garlic butter and White Zinfandel. Baked to perfection!!! plus two sides of your choice

$20.95
Nellie's Famous Fried Shrimp

Eight Large, Jumbo Shrimp fried golden brown in panko crumbs, served with lemon cocktail sauce. Plus two sides of your choice

$23.95
Island Style Coconut Shrimp

Eight Large Jumbo Shrimp coconut fried with our famous tropical dipping sauce. Plus two sides of your choice

$24.95
Stone Ground Mustard Baked Salmon

Fresh Salmon, A heartly 8oz filet, baked with our stone grounf mustard Sauce & golden panko crumbs. Plus two sides of your choice

$21.95
"Amazing" Grilled Salmon Oscar

An 8 oz filet baked with Local crab and baby asparagus in our famous Oscar Sauce. Plus two sides of your choice

$24.95
Blue Crab Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

"Oh wow!" This Nellie's house specialty... Baked off to perfection these Island treats will make you dance again! Plus two sides of your choice

$24.95
Bimini Scallop Boat

Seven Fresh Sea Scallops broiled in nellie's famous scampi sauce. Kissed by golden panko crumbs. Plus two sides of your choice

$25.95
Ultimate crab Cakes

Made with blue crabmeat, then pan seared perfectly our way-" The tastiest treat" you'll cry for more

$17.95
Spiced Stuffed Scallops

Bonzed "island Style" As these sweet beauties are nestled over our famous crabmeat stuffing. Plus two sides of your choice

$27.95
Florida Broiled Seafood Platter

Enjoy! Red grouper, Jumbo shrimp and large sea scallops have the star role! Supporting cast of seasonal vegetable and smashed red potato!

$27.95
Nellie's Fresh Catch

Since 2009 Nervous Nellie's has been sourcing and preparing the freshest availabe seafood. Our "Fresh Catch" features great local seafood prepared the way you like it: Either Broiled, Bronzed, or Blackened. In addition, add tow sides from these choice Plank Fries, Mashed Potatoes, Wild Rice Pilaf, Black Bean Rice, Chef's Vegetable, or fresh Seasonal Fruit Plus fresh Homemade Breads

$20.99
Nellie's Gumbo

Imagine an array of jumbo shrimp, Plump scallops, crabmeat, fresh catch of the day and sauteed sausage in a tasty gumbo over fluffy rice - to boot

$17.95
Our Famous Seafood Pasta

Our wonderful recipe sporting fresh lobster, scallops, succulent shrimp, fresh catch and more is the talk of many a review!! Blessed in a marvelous lobster cream sauce Enjoy this tantalizing treat

$20.95
Nervous Nellie's Incredible Island Jambalaya

A ranson of gluf shrimp, jerk seasoned chicken breast, and spicy Andouille sausage in a rich tomato sauce over streaming rice

$19.95
Nellie's Ultimate Steam Pot

A mother load of Steamed Clams, Oysters, Mussels, Shrimp, and crab clusters and more!!! Served up shore style with red bliss potatoes, carrots, corn on the cob, drawn butter and fresh breads from Nervous Nellie's bakery

$36.99
Chef's Bounty Crab Feast

Alaskan King and Opelio Queen ale steamed and prepared prefectly! Maine Mussle and Atlantic Middleneck clams with garlic butter forthe dipper- Butter be hungry

$39.99
Island Steamed Crab Legs and Cluster

Tasty Opelio and king Crab steamed with Island spices. Served shore-style with red bliss Potatoes, carrots, and corn on the cab assorted fresh breads

$29.99
Maine Lobster Pot

How about this? 11/2 pound lobster, steamed off so tastefully. Sided with the traditional shore lunch side: red bliss potatoes, carrots, and corn on the cob, assorted breads from the bakery and drawan butter

$29.99
Ale Steamed Jumbo Shrimp

Steamed off with Island spices- Served up with all the fix'ins A heap'in of fun fingers foods

$23.99
Nellie's USDA Char- Grilled New York Srtip

Fire seared 16 oz. full-boiled strip sirloin, seasoned and grilled to your specifivation

$21.95
Our 8 oz Filet Mignon

The most tender cut of Midwestern corn fed beef. Melt in your mouth tender

$26.99
North and South

Our 16 oz. Hand Carved Ribeye, seasoned just right, plus 12 oz. of Alaskan king Crab legs. From the Midwest and Dutch Harbor, Alaska!

-
Our Traditional Surf and Turf

A n8 oz. Filet MIgnon paired with a 5oz. cold water Lobster Tail and drwan butter. The best of Midwestern beef and Great ALtlantic fisheries!

-
Our 8oz Filet Mignon

The most tender cut of Midwestern corn fed beef. Melt in your mouth tender

$26.99
Nellie's Steak Oscar

Bless your steak with Blue carb, Asparagus, and Oscar Sauce for an additional

$6.00
Sonama Country WIne and Mushroom Medley

Crown your steak with a fresh mushroom medley sauteed in butter, herbs, red wine, and demi-glace

$3.00
Roasted Chicken Alfredo

Enjoy ou pasta of the day with this wonderful olde fashion recipe-sporting tender chicken breast, sun dried tomatoes and more-This will make you dance in time!!!!

$16.95
Chicken Parmesan!

Lightly fried tender chicken breast-Topped with fresh mozzarella and savory tomato sauce

$16.95
Four Cheese Tri-Color Tortellini and Jumbo Shrimp

Blessed with our vodka tomato cream sauce Oh!

$17.95
Golden Macaroni and Cheese

We add crisp smoked Applewood bacon and grilled chicken-Fresh parsley look-out!

$14.95
BBQ Chicken'N More

Consider the peppers, onions and colby Jack

$13.95
Southern BBQ Pork Quesadillas

Our special recipe will make you whistle away!!!

$13.95
Ragin' Cajin' Chicken & Sausage Quesadilla

Smoked sausage, tender chicken, carmelized onions, sweet peppers and savory cheeses

$13.95
Seafood Quesadilla

Blessed with plump shrimp, scallops, fresh catch and crabmeat- Make this a perfect partner to sweet peppers, onions and melted cheeses

$15.95
Very Veggie Quesadilla

This tortilla is bursting with grilled and roasted vegetables, smothered with savory cheeses and black beans to-boot

$10.95
Fried Jumbo Shrimp

we pick'um big Lightly battered and tastefully fried Sit back and enjoy

$17.95
Ale Battered Grouper

A heap'in help'in of Nellie orignal recipe Wow This is the real! deal

$18.95
Oh! Chicken Fingers

"No bones about it"!! Tender and tasty! Plain, Hot saucey, Boom Boom or Teriyaki Garlic

$11.95
Fried Clam Strips

Hand dipped in our special recipe! A loaded basket with cocktail & tartar for the dipper

$14.95
Ale Battered Jumbo Shrimp 'n Fish

This ole-time favorite is lightly fried in a special recipe!! Ole Malt Vinegar to boot!

$18.95
Crispy Jumbo Scallops

Did you hear about these yet? Oh boy!! Always brag'in Large and succulen- "A house Specially"

$18.95
Golden Fried Shrimp and Scallops

Our most populor "daily double" Golden brown and delish

$19.95
Olde Fashioned Ale Battered Fish 'n Chips

This tavern favorite will carry on the tradition. We call it Heaven right here!!

$14.95
Hook, Line and Sinker

Lightly fried, You provide the style!!! Then we'll provide this taste combo of fresh catch, large shrimp, large scallops and fried clasm Served up with the plank fries and coleslaw Better be hungry

$25.95
Sizzling Steak and Chicken Fajitas

Tender marinated flank steak and plump chicken breast create this memorable dish with seared bell peppers, sweet onions and more. Served up with all the fix'ns

$16.95
Ultimate Seafood Fajitas

Everything you could imagine-Enjoy! Served up with all your needs-The Greatest

$18.95
jumbo Shrimp and scallops Stir-Fry

Pan -sizzled with fresh veggies

$17.95
Thai Chicken Stir-Fry

Say, coconut milk, garlic-chili tender chicken and stir-fry vegetable are the stars of this show Fluffy rice-Yeah

$15.95
Chocolate Mud Puddle

Decadent Chocolate mousse, on crushed Oreo cookies, with a rich Caramel Sauce and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream. Enough to share

$6.95
Florida Key Lime Pie

A touch of the tropics! Tort, sweet, and delicious

$6.95
Mile High Carrot Cake

A Nellie's tradtion. A tall piece of carrot cake with creamy cream cheese frosting

$6.95
Strawberry

-
Banana

-
Raspberry

-
Peach

-
Pina Coloda

-
Mango

-
Strawberry-Banana

-
Mighty Chocolate

-
Cheeseburger

Char-grilled 1/4 lb fresh ground beef with melted American cheese. Served with fries

-
Chicken Fingers

Hand-cut chicken breast, prepared with our special recipe. Then lightly fried to a golden brown. Served with fries

-
Creamy Mac and Cheese

Mama's favorite recipe!

-
Our famous Hot Dog

On a home baked bun. With golden fries

-
Roni's & Butter

Rigatoni pasta with tasty butter Oh!

-
Lightly Fried Chicken Sandwich

A great experience!!

-
Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Old reliable grilled on artisan bread with American cheese

-
Fresh Ground

-
Gourmet Coffees

-
Hot Tea from

-
Around the World

-
Steam'in Hot Chocolate

-
Sweet Iced tea

Free refills

$2.99
Brewed Iced tea

Free refills

$2.99
Iced coffee

$2.99
Milk

$2.99
Chocolate Milk

$2.99
juices

Apple, Cranberry & Tomato

$2.99
Fresh Squeezed Orange & Grapefruit Juice

$2.99
Lemonade

$2.99
Bottled Spring & Sparkling waters

$2.99
Coca Cola

Fountain Sodas

$2.99

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

Browse Restaurants | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | FAQ | Restaurant Owners | Contact us

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Crunchbase AngelList Tumblr Instagram

© 2020 BringMeThat, Inc