Caribbean Pie Company - Sarasota, FL

Our award-winning key lime pie. Try this amazing treat in a graham cracker crust. It's the right combination of tart, sweet and tangy. This is a favorite of all who try it. Pie will be delivered with whipped topping unless you indicate PLAIN on order.

Enjoy your favorite key lime pie topped with chocolate. Our award-winning Key lime pie is dipped in Belgian chocolate for a double treat. Sensational.

Try a key lime pie that doesn't follow the norm. Tropical fruit pie has raspberry, mango and guava puree swirled into the top of a key lime filling in a graham cracker crust. Pie is delivered with a whipped topping border. Indicate on order if you desire it plain, without the topping.

Our coconut cream pie is unlike anything you have ever tasted. It's a creamy intense coconut with shredded coconut and topped with toasted coconut in a graham cracker crust.

This is a 2 layer chocolate pie in an oreo crust. It has a layer of chocolate ganache on the bottom, is topped with a light and fluffy chocolate mousse and shaved chocolate covering the top of the pie. Topped off with whipped cream. If you have a chocolate craving, be sure to snag this one.

Our chocolate swirl key lime is a delicious combination of tart key lime and rich dark chocolate. This is our classic key lime pie swirled with dark chocolate into the top. This is a must try. Will have a whipped toppi g border unless ordered plain.

This banana cream with salted caramel is just as mouth-watering as its name. You will know exactly what we mean once you get your first bite of sea salt, caramel and banana all infused together. Yum!

A tasty variation of our award-winning key lime pie. Key lime pie is swirled with a rich raspberry melba sauce. This provides a little different taste, but the key lime flavor is dominant. A beautiful presentation for a delicious pie that is always a hit. Will have a whipped topping border unless ordered plain.

Our traditional key lime pie swirled with mango in a graham cracker crust for an extra burst of flavor. Pie will be delivered with whipped topping unless you indicate PLAIN on order.

An old-time taste that may bring back memories. The orange creamsicle is reminiscent of the ice cream and popsicle combination of yesteryear. The tart orange taste is perfectly balanced with a creamy smooth taste. Pie will be delivered with whipped topping unless you indicate PLAIN.

We all love peanut butter, so why not take a chance with this rich, creamy peanut butter pie topped with chopped peanuts in a graham cracker crust. One of our newest pies with great reviews. Yum!

A tart taster is a great way to enjoy many of our delicious varieties. Each sampler has one key lime, chocolate silk, banana cream or salted caramel, tropical key lime and coconut tart included. You can decide which is your favorite and follow with a whole pie!

Our homemade fudge is made with real cream and butter. Available in a variety of flavors, chocolate, key lime, peanut butter, vanilla, and chocolate nut. Cut to order or in pre-packed state of Florida or rectangular packages.