Bring_me_that_logo

Sylvester Fish Market - Avalon, NJ

503 21st Street, Avalon, NJ 08202
NJ > Avalon > 08202
Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Cold Appetizers

6 Piece Clams on a 1/2 Shell

$11.00
Shrimp Cocktail

$16.50
Crabmeat Cocktail

$22.00
Crab Fingers

$20.62

Hot Appetizers

Fried Calamari

$15.12
Jumbo Clam Strips

$13.75
Grouper Tenders

$16.50
Single Crabcake

Choice of broiled or fried.

$19.25
Steamed Shrimp

$17.88
French Fries

$5.50
Pint French Fries

$8.25
Quart French Fries

$12.38
Chicken Fingers

$9.62
Mozzarella Sticks

$9.62
Steamed Clams

$19.25

Mussels

Red Sauce

$22.00
Spicy Red Sauce

$22.00
Mussels Sylvester’s

White wine, butter and garlic sauce with shallots, herbs and spices.

$22.00

Beverages

16 oz. Cola

$3.88
16 oz. 7UP

$3.88
16 oz. Diet Cola

$3.88
16 oz. Stewarts Root Beer

$3.88
16 oz. Gingerale

$3.88
16 oz. Iced Tea

$3.88
16 oz. Lemonade

$3.88
Pitcher

Serves 4.

$11.00
Coffee

$2.12

Soups

Clam Chowder Soup

$6.88
New England White Soup

$6.88
Manhattan Red Soup

$6.88
She Crab Soup

Jumbo lump and lump crab.

$8.25

Extra Sides

Cole Slaw

$1.38
Apple Sauce

$1.38
Baked Potato

$2.12
Corn on the Cob

$2.75
Mac and Cheese

$6.88
Dinner Roll

$1.38

Platters

Order Crab Salad food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Crab Salad

$22.00
Order Shrimp and Crab Salad food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Shrimp and Crab Salad

$24.75
Shrimp Salad

$19.25

Sandwiches

Fish Tacos

Mahi.

$20.62
Chicken Caesar Wrap

$13.75
Grouper Tenders Wrap

$16.50
Fried Flounder Sandwich

$16.50
Crab Cake

$20.62
Blackened Mahi Sandwich

$16.50
Shrimp Salad Sandwich

$16.50
Carb Salad Sandwich

$20.62
Chicken Filet Sandwich

$12.38
Hamburger

$11.00
Cheeseburger

$13.75
Hot Dog Sandwich

$9.62

Salads

Caesar Salad

$6.88 +
House Salad

$6.88 +

Broiled Dinner

Order Salmon food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Salmon

$34.38
Mahi Mahi

$33.00
Flounder Local

$37.12
Crab Cake

$39.88
Shrimp

$33.00
Scallops Local

$37.12
Stuffed Flounder

$41.25
Stuffed Shrimp

Served with our crab cake.

$39.88
Seafood Combination

Flounder, shrimp, crab cake and scallops.

$33.00

Surf and Turf

Order Fried Shrimp food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Fried Shrimp

$49.50
Order Broiled Scallops food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Broiled Scallops

$50.88
Crab Cake

$53.62
Broiled Shrimp

$49.50
Fried Scallops

$50.88
Fried Flounder

$50.88
Broiled Flounder

$50.88

Meats and Chicken

6 oz. Filet Mignon

$35.75
6 oz. Hungry Man Filet

$64.62
Grilled Chicken Filet

All white meat.

$12.38
Chicken Parmigiana

Served with linguin.

$26.12
Chicken Fingers

$15.12

Fried Dinner

Order Fried Shrimp food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Fried Shrimp

$33.00
Fried Flounder Local

$37.12
Fried Scallops

$37.12
2 Piece Fried Crabcakes

$39.88
Jumbo Calm Strips

$26.12
Fried Seafood Combination

Flounder, shrimp, crab cake and scallops.

$45.38

Fried Combination

Flounder and Shrimp

$35.75
Flounder and Scallops

$37.12
Crab Cake and Flounder

$38.50
Crab Cake and Shrimp

$38.50
Crab Cake and Scallops

$38.50
Shrimp and Scallops

$35.75

Fresh From The Grill

Order Tuna food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
Tuna

$37.12
Swordfish

$34.38

Children’s Menu

Order KIds Linguini food online from Sylvester Fish Market store, Avalon on bringmethat.com
KIds Linguini

$12.38
Kids Fried Flounder

$20.62
Kids Fried Shrimp

$16.50
Kids Grilled Chicken Filet

$13.75
KIds Hamburger

$13.75
Kids Cheeseburger

$15.12
Kids Hot Dog

$12.38
Kids Chicken Fingers

$13.75
Kids Mac and Cheese

$11.00

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews