Bring_me_that_logo

Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops

215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
NY > Ithaca > 14850
Pickup
|
Delivery

Popular Items

Plain

$12.15 +
Pudgie’s Package (For only)

One cheese sheet pizza – 20 Buffalo style chicken wings and 2 quart of Soda

$39.06
Stromboli

Folded pizza dough filled with Pudgies pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, ham, peppers, mozzarella and American Cheese, Basted with Butter.

$5.21
Chicken Wings

Buffalo style chicken wings served with Bleu Cheese with BBQ, Mild, Medium, Hot or Extra Hot sauce.

$11.24 +
Quart (32oz)

$2.60

Main Menu

Daily Specials

Order 2 Cheese Slices & 16 oz. Pepsi food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
2 Cheese Slices & 16 oz. Pepsi

$6.36
Order 2 Pepperoni Slices & 16oz. Pepsi food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
2 Pepperoni Slices & 16oz. Pepsi

$6.65
Order 1 Slice of Stromboli & 16oz. Pepsi food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
1 Slice of Stromboli & 16oz. Pepsi

$6.95
Order 1 Cheese Slice, 3 Bread Sticks & 16oz. Pepsi food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
1 Cheese Slice, 3 Bread Sticks & 16oz. Pepsi

$6.36
Order Any Cold or Hot Sub, Fries & 16oz. Pepsi food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Any Cold or Hot Sub, Fries & 16oz. Pepsi

$11.58
Order Pudgie Dog food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie Dog

$2.86
Order Pudgie Dog with Cheese food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie Dog with Cheese

$3.18
Order Pudgie Dog with Meat sauce food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie Dog with Meat sauce

$3.30
Order Pudgie Dog with Both food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie Dog with Both

$3.61
Order Dog, Fries & 16oz. Drinks food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Dog, Fries & 16oz. Drinks

$6.65
Order Family / Student Pack (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Family / Student Pack (For Only)

Large cheese pizza – 10 Buffalo style chicken wings and 1 quart of Pepsi

$27.20
Order Snack Pack (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Snack Pack (For Only)

A medium cheese pizza- 10 Buffalo style chicken wings

$19.99
Order Triple Treat (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Triple Treat (For Only)

3 Medium one topping pizzas

$29.99
Order Pudgie’s Package (For only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie’s Package (For only)

One cheese sheet pizza – 20 Buffalo style chicken wings and 2 quart of Soda

$39.06
Order Family Pleaser (For only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Family Pleaser (For only)

A large cheese pizza, 2 Pasta, 2 Large Bread sticks and 2 garden salad

$36.24

Crowd Pleaser
Some items in this group may require 12 hour notice. Please call in advance of your event

Order Large Garden Salad food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Large Garden Salad

Made with iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes, onions and your choice dressing

$22.49
Order Large Rigatoni (Serves 20-25) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Large Rigatoni (Serves 20-25)

Made with our famous homemade spaghetti sauce topped with mozzarella cheese

$42.49
Order Bread Sticks By the Sheet food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Bread Sticks By the Sheet

Our homemade garlic bread sticks served with marinara sauce

$21.24
Order Sub Platter food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Sub Platter

Made with 5 feet subs cut into 20 servings. Choose up to 5 different Subs to match your needs

$43.74
Order Veggie Platter (Serves 20-25) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Veggie Platter (Serves 20-25)

Made with broccoli, cauliflower, baby carrots, green pepper, celery and ranch dressing

$32.49

Pizza
Fresh Custom made Pizza - Millions Sold"

Order Plain food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Plain

$12.15 +
Order Toppings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Toppings

$1.86 +
Order Snack Pack (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Snack Pack (For Only)

A medium cheese pizza- 10 Buffalo style chicken wings

$19.99
Order Family / Student Pack (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Family / Student Pack (For Only)

Large cheese pizza – 10 Buffalo style chicken wings and 1 quart of Pepsi

$27.20
Order Triple Treat (For Only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Triple Treat (For Only)

3 Medium one topping pizzas

$29.99
Order Pudgie’s Package (For only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie’s Package (For only)

One cheese sheet pizza – 20 Buffalo style chicken wings and 2 quart of Soda

$39.06
Order Family Pleaser (For only) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Family Pleaser (For only)

A large cheese pizza, 2 Pasta, 2 Large Bread sticks and 2 garden salad

$36.24

Speciality Pizzas

Order Gourmet Chicken Wings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Gourmet Chicken Wings

Made with Pudgie’s famous Buffalo style medium wing sauce, All white chicken chunks and topped with 100% mozzarella cheese

$15.88 +
Order The Works food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
The Works

Made with our homemade pizza sauce topped with pepperoni, meat sauce, sausage, onions, peppers and mushrooms covered in mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection!

$21.46 +
Order Vegetarian food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Vegetarian

Made with our homemade pizza sauce topped with fresh tomato slices, onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli covered in mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection!

$21.46 +
Order Garlic Pizza food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Garlic Pizza

A buttered Pizza Shell covered with garlic and mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection!

$14.01 +

Wings

Order Buffalo Style Chicken Wings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

Served with Bleu Cheese.

$11.24 +
Order Boneless Wings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Boneless Wings

Served with Bleu Cheese.

$11.24 +

Delicious Cold Subs!

Order Deal of a Meal food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Deal of a Meal

Any cold sub french fries and a 16 oz. soda of your choice!

$11.58
Order Ham & Cheese Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Ham & Cheese Sub

Sliced Ham, American Cheese, fresh lettuce, onions, tomato slices, mayonnaise and Italian sub dressing

$6.71 +
Order Super Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Super Sub

Boiled Ham, American & Italian Salami, American Cheese, fresh lettuce, onions, tomato slices, mayonnaise and Italian sub dressing.

$6.71 +
Order Cold Roast Beef food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Cold Roast Beef

USDA top round beef fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions, mayonnaise and Italian sub dressing.

$6.71 +
Order Italian Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Italian Sub

Italian Salami, Capicola Ham, American Cheese fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions, mayonnaise and Italian sub dressing.

$6.71 +
Order Turkey Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Turkey Sub

Fresh sliced Turkey, fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions, mayonnaise and Italian sub dressing.

$6.71 +
Order Vegetarian Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Vegetarian Sub

Fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions, double cheese, Italian sub dressing and mayonnaise. (optional hot or sweet peppers and black olives)

$6.71 +

Delicious Hot Subs

Order Deal of a Meal food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Deal of a Meal

Any hot sub french fries and a 16 oz. soda of your choice!

$11.58
Order Pudgie Burger food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pudgie Burger

1/3 lb of 100% ground beef, served on a toasted roll with melted cheese, lettuce, tomato slices, onions and mayonnaise.

$9.84
Order Hot Roast Beef food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Hot Roast Beef

USDA top round beef served with butter and BBQ sauce.(Horseradish optional) Served steaming hot on a fresh baked roll.

$9.84
Order Hot Meatball food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Hot Meatball

Ground beef blended with Pudgies very own special seasoning served with Pudgies spaghetti sauce, served on a toasted roll. Your choice of Mozzarella or American Cheese.

$9.84
Order Grilled Ham & Cheese food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Grilled Ham & Cheese

Grilled ham and cheese on a toasted roll topped with fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions and mayonnaise.

$9.84
Order Hot Chicken Subs food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Hot Chicken Subs

Chicken breast topped with fresh lettuce, tomato slices, onions and mayonnaise or choose Parmesan Chicken Breast topped with Pudgies spaghetti sauce, served on a toasted roll with Mozzarella or American Cheese

$9.84
Order Cheese Steak food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Cheese Steak

Top sirloin steak sliced thin and topped with melted cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayonnaise. Grilled peppers and mushrooms are optional.

$9.84
Order Buffalo Chicken Sub food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Chicken Sub

Chicken Breast dipped in your choose of any of our wing sauces, served on a toasted roll with Mozzarella or American cheese

$9.84

Stromboli

Order Stromboli food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Stromboli

Folded pizza dough filled with Pudgies pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, ham, peppers, mozzarella and American Cheese, Basted with Butter.

$5.21
Order Stromboli Special food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Stromboli Special

A single slice of stromboli with a 16 ounce soda of your choice for only

$6.95

From The Fryer

Order Mozzarella Stix food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Mozzarella Stix

Five Battered deep fried Mozzarella Stix served with a side of spaghetti sauce! Only per order!

$6.65
Order Chicken Fingers food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Chicken Fingers

Four delicious deep fried Chicken Fingers served with BBQ, Blue Cheese or Ranch dressing or try one of our wing sauces mild, med, or hot only

$8.74
Order French Fries food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
French Fries

Golden brown shoestring french fries Only per order.

$2.60
Order Chicken Wings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Chicken Wings

Buffalo style chicken wings served with Bleu Cheese with BBQ, Mild, Medium, Hot or Extra Hot sauce.

$11.24 +
Order Boneless Wings food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Boneless Wings

Boneless chicken wings served with Bleu Cheese with BBQ, Mild, Medium, Hot or Extra Hot sauce.

$11.24 +
Order Pizza Frette food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Pizza Frette

Fried Dough Covered in confectionery sugar. Only Per order

$3.44
Order Bread Sticks food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Bread Sticks

Lightly seasoned with garlic, Italian spices, butter and grated cheese. Served with spaghetti sauce

$3.74
Order Side Salad food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Side Salad

Fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, onions and your choice of dressing. Choose from French, Ranch, Blue Cheese or Italian

$4.49
Order Garden Salad food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Garden Salad

Fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, onions and your choice of dressing. Choose from French, Ranch, Blue Cheese or Italian

$6.24
Order Chicken Salad food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad

Fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, onions, American Cheese, Diced chicken Breast and your choice of dressing. Choose from French, Blue Cheese, Italian or try our famous wings sauce

$8.10
Order Buffalo Chicken Salad food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, onions, diced chicken breast with your choose sauce, American Cheese. Choose From French, Ranch, Blue Cheese or Italian

$8.10

Beverages

Order Medium (16oz) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Medium (16oz)

$2.19
Order Quart (32oz) food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Quart (32oz)

$2.60
Order Bottled Water food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Bottled Water

$2.02
Order Can Soda food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Can Soda

$1.65
Order Slush Puppie food online from Pudgie's Pizza and Sub Shops store, Ithaca on bringmethat.com
Slush Puppie

$2.60

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2024 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ