Bring_me_that_logo

Islamorada Fish Company is closed temporarily.

Islamorada Fish Company - Islamorada, FL

81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
FL > Islamorada > 33036

Order from similar restaurants nearby

Online ordering is not available here. Order from one of these restaurants instead. This restaurant's menu is still below.

Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Appetizers

Seafood-stuffed Mushrooms

$9.94
Conch Fritters

$8.69
Squid Rings

house specialty

$9.94
Smoked Fish Dip

house specialty

$9.94
Crab Cake

$11.19
Spinach Con Queso

$9.94
Alligator

$11.19
Conch Salad

$9.31
Cracked Conch

$11.19
Coconut Shrimp

$11.19
Fish Tacos

$11.19

Homemade Soups

Clam Chowder (white)

$4.94
Conch Chowder (red)

$4.94

Salads

House

mixed greens topped with fresh vegetables and mixed cheeses

$8.69
Caesar

chopped fresh romaine with dressing, croutons, and parmesan cheese

$8.69
Greek

mixed greens, feta cheese, greek olives, tomatoes, onions and pepperoncinis

$11.19

Salad Toppers

Fresh Dolphin

fried or grilled

$19.94
Scallops (1/4-lb.)

fried or grilled

$19.94
Chicken Breast

fried or grilled

$14.94
Shrimp Skewer

grilled

$21.19
Yellowfin Tuna

grilled

$22.44
Florida Lobster Tail

grilled

-

Raw Bar

Shrimp Cocktail

$12.44
Steamed Clams

$9.94
Raw Oysters

$9.94
Old Bay Shrimp (hot Or Cold)

$11.19
Stone Crab Claws (seasonal)

-
Island Sampler

2 crab cakes, conch fritters & alligator

$17.44

Sandwiches

Dolphin

fried or grilled

$16.81
Grouper

fried or grilled

$17.44
Chicken

fried or grilled

$12.44
Fried Cracked Conch

$16.81
Islamorada Fish Sandwich

house specialty. (fried or grilled) grouper topped with sautéed onions and american cheese and served on a kaiser roll

$18.69
Snapper

fried or grilled

$16.19
Tuna

$17.44
Crab Cake

$17.44
Cheeseburger

$12.44
Grouper Reuben

house specialty. (fried or grilled) fresh grouper topped with thousand island slaw dressing and swiss cheese and served on our grilled texas-cut rye bread

$18.69

Specialties

Dolphin Chardonnay

freshly baked dolphin topped with fresh mushrooms and tomatoes in a california chardonnay sauce

$28.69
Stuffed Dolphin

fresh dolphin stuffed with our herb-seasoned crabmeat stuffing and garnished with a tropical mango salsa and topped with a creamy hollandaise sauce

$29.94
Stuffed Shrimp

succulent shrimp stuffed with our herb-seasoned crabmeat stuffing and topped with hollandaise sauce

$27.44
Tuna Wasabi

sushi-grade yellowfin tuna seared to temperature, covered in sesame seeds & topped with our islamorada wasabi sauce

$27.44
Snapper Française

fresh yellowtail snapper filet dipped in a seasoned egg batter and sautéed to golden brown and topped with a lemon butter sauce

$27.44
Stuffed Florida Lobster (seasonal)

whole fresh florida lobster stuffed with shrimp, scallops and our herb seasoned crabmeat stuffing

-
Stone Crab Claws (seasonal)

fresh medium or large stone crab claws—served hot or cold. served with cole slaw

-
Grouper Portofino

fresh grouper, blackened and topped with key west shrimp in a brandied lobster cream sauce

$28.69

Dry Land

Strip Steak

12 oz. aged black angus center cut sirloin

$28.69
St. Louis Ribs

full slab of tender ribs smothered in islamorada’s own tropical bbq sauce

$24.94
Top Sirloin

8 oz. u.s.d.a.

$19.94
Chicken Piccata

chicken breast filets dusted in flour and sautéed golden brown. topped with a lemon caper sauce

$18.69

Pasta

Key West Pasta

key west shrimp tossed in a rich creamy lobster sauce and plated on a bed of linguine

$23.69
Chicken Alfredo

blackened chicken tossed in a creamy alfredo sauce and plated on a bed of linguine

$18.69
Pasta Morada

our house special features large shrimp, mussels, clams and lobster tossed in a fresh clam sauce. served over linguine with a touch of marinara sauce

$27.44

Fried Baskets

Dolphin

$23.69
Calamari

$16.19
Tenderized American Alligator

$18.69
Sea Scallops

$23.69
Shrimp

$19.94
Clam Strips

$16.19
Oysters

$17.44
Cracked Conch

$17.44
Combo Baskets

choice of any 2 above

$26.19
Grouper

$26.19
Crab Cakes

$23.69
Whole Fried Yellowtail Snapper

-

Sides

Potato Salad

$1.88
Sautéed Mushrooms

$2.44
Sautéed Onions

$1.88
Side Garden/caesar

$5.62
Vegetable Of The Day

$3.12
Cole Slaw

$1.88
Rice

$2.44
Feta Cheese

$2.44
Small Greek

$7.44
Basket Of Fries

$3.69

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ