Johnny's New York Style Pizza of Alpharetta - Alpharetta, GA

AVAILABLE FOR PICKUP THIS WEEK ONLY (August 16th-19th)! Creamy peanut butter filling over a layer of chocolate ganache, topped with a peanut butter crumble and drizzled ganache, all in our signature all-butter pie crust! - Whole Pie

A brand new recipe available for a limited time only! A coffee ice cream filling inside a chocolate wafer crust, covered with a light layer of chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and chocolate curls. - Regular

Birthday cake batter flavor in pie… yes, please!! This sweet and silky custard is made with cake batter filling, festive sprinkles, and topped with our signature, buttercream frosting. This pie is perfect for any occasion or celebration, whether it be a birthday, work promotion, anniversary, or “just because”! - Whole Pie

For a limited time only, select 4 petite pies and get 10% off - 4 Petite Pies

Cross dinner & dessert off the list... we have it covered! This bundle features your choice of our most popular sweet pies and savory dinner pies. It also makes a wonderful gift for the person who just needs a meal taken off their plate! Please choose your savory pie (Take & Bake comes frozen and you can bake it at home or choose Baked if you'd like us to bake it for you in store) and your favorite sweet pie below. - Sweet + Savory Pie

Your No-Prep Meal Kit! Pick your favorite 3 dinner pies and check 3 meals off your list this month. Pies store in the freezer for up to 6 months and no thawing is required to bake. Pies are 10 inches in diameter and serve 8 - 10 slices. - 3 Dinner Pies

A medley of sweet, local Georgia peaches picked at their peak of flavor, and baked to perfection in our signature, Southern Baked, all-butter crust. The best part: this pie is topped with our made-from-scratch browned butter sugar oat streusel. The tastes of summer is abound in this cobbler style pie! - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Slices)

August Pie of the Month! A summertime favorite, fresh blueberries baked to their peak of flavor and topped with our signature brown sugar streusel topping. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

August Pie of the Month! A summertime favorite, fresh blueberries baked to their peak of flavor and topped with our signature brown sugar streusel topping. - 5" Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - Single

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - Half Dozen

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - Dozen

You Asked, We Listened! Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Single

You Asked, We Listened! Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Half Dozen

You Asked, We Listened! Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Dozen

Our Key Lime Pie is the perfect dessert to cool off with on a hot summer day. Made with fresh squeezed key lime juice and topped with dollops of fresh cream inside a homemade graham cracker crust. Perfect balance of tart citrus and sweetness. This pie is made to keep frozen until you are ready to cut and serve. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

Our Key Lime Pie is the perfect dessert to cool off with on a hot summer day. Made with fresh squeezed key lime juice and topped with dollops of fresh cream inside a homemade graham cracker crust. Perfect balance of tart citrus and sweetness. This pie is made to keep frozen until you are ready to cut and serve. - 5" Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Tea Towel - Vintage Dot

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Tea Towel - Blue Stripe

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Tea Towel - Oatmeal Gingham

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Tea Towel - Blue Gingham

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Recipe Cards

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Notepad

We've partnered up with our friends at Heirloomed to provide a beautiful collection featuring paper and linen products that can be passed down for generations. Pairs perfect with homemade pie and makes a great gift! - Market List

Locally grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, all-butter crust. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

Bursting with sour cherries and full of flavor, our cherry pies are the perfect combination of both tart and sweet crowned with an old-fashion lattice, all butter crust. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 5” Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. - 5” Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. - 10” Gluten Free Pie (8-10 Servings)

Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. - 5” Gluten Free Pie (1-2 Servings)

A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! - 10" Whole Pie (8-10 Servings)

A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! - 5” Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! - 10” Gluten Free Pie (8-10 Servings)

A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! - 5” Gluten Free Pie (1-2 Servings)

Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 10" Whole Pie ('8-10 Servings)

Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 5” Petite Pie (1-2 Servings)

Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 10” Gluten Free Pie (8-10 Servings)

Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. - 5” Gluten Free Pie (1-2 Servings)

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 10" Take & Bake Pie

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 10” Baked Pie

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 10” Hot Pie

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 5” Take & Bake Pie

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 5” Baked Pie

Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. - 5” Hot Pie

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 10" Take & Bake Pie '

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 10” Baked Pie

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 10” Hot Pie

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 5” Take & Bake Pie

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 5” Baked Pie

A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. - 5” Hot Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 10" Take & Bake Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 10” Baked Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 10” Hot Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 5” Take & Bake Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 5” Baked Pie

Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! - 5” Hot Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 10" Take & Bake Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 10” Baked Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 10” Hot Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 5” Take & Bake Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 5” Baked Pie

A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies. - 5” Hot Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 10" Baked Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 10” Hot Petite Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 5” Baked Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 5” Hot Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 10” Gluten Free Pie

Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. - 5” Gluten Free Pie

Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration - Whole Size

Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration - Petite Size

Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration - Gluten Free Whole Size

Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration - Gluten Free Petite Size

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 10" Baked Pie

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 10” Hot Pie

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 5” Baked Pie

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 5” Hot Pie

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 10” Gluten Free Pie

Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. - 5” Gluten Free Pie

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - Single

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - Half Dozen

Your favorite treat is now available in a new flavor! Our hand pies you know and love are now available with a blueberry filling that will leave you wanting more! Stock up on this summer treat while supplies last! - One Dozen

Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Single

Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Half Dozen

Our signature hand pie filled with our incredible peach filling has returned for a limited time! Save money by stocking up while supplies last! - Dozen

A little bit about Amanda Wilbanks and her newest cookbook, Southern Baked: Celebrating Life With Pie GROWING UP, I NEVER THOUGHT I’D BE A PIE BAKER. A COOK, MAYBE, BUT NOT A BAKER. After all, my culinary role models were stellar. Growing up in the South, I was always a hands-on cook, raised in my mother’s and grandmothers’ kitchens, rolling out biscuit dough and stirring aromatic pots over the stove, shelling peas, and canning bounty from our garden. The hustle and bustle of it all was like a second language to me—one that involved touch and taste and smell as much as it did sound or sight. Then, when we all met around the table to enjoy the fruits of our labor, I felt connected to my family on a deeper level. I knew from a young age that food was my favorite way of saying, “I love you.” Using our famous, all-butter crust recipe, I've compiled 12 months of recipes for all of life's special occasions. The recipes in this book are tried-and-true. Tested again and again in my own kitc - Southern Baked Cookbook

Includes a can of Jittery Joe’s house blend coffee, a Southern Baked mug, your choice of a whole sweet pie and a personalized note for your favorite coffee lover (please leave your note in the notes section below and choice of sweet pie) - Bundle

Includes a gift wrapped cookbook, a box of our signature Gluten Free pie crust mix and a personalized note for your favorite pie maker (please leave your note in the notes section below) - Bundle

Includes your choice of a gift wrapped whole savory pie with a personalized note (please leave your note in the notes section below and choice of savory pie) - Baked

Includes your choice of a gift wrapped whole savory pie with a personalized note (please leave your note in the notes section below and choice of savory pie) - Frozen

Includes a gift wrapped cookbook, a box of our signature pie crust mix and a personalized note for your favorite pie maker (please leave your note in the notes section below) - Bundle

Includes your choice of a gift wrapped whole savory pie with a personalized note (please leave your note in the notes section below and choice of savory pie) - Baked

Includes your choice of a gift wrapped whole savory pie with a personalized note (please leave your note in the notes section below and choice of savory pie) - Frozen

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

Gift Certificate

How it works: 1. Place your order by selecting a 3, 6, or 12 Month membership 2. Select the date and time you'd like to pick up your certificates 3. A member of our team will have your certificates ready at our pickup counter 4. Stop by anytime through the month to redeem your certificate for a sweet pie of your choice - 3 Month Pie of The Month Club

How it works: 1. Place your order by selecting a 3, 6, or 12 Month membership 2. Select the date and time you'd like to pick up your certificates 3. A member of our team will have your certificates ready at our pickup counter 4. Stop by anytime through the month to redeem your certificate for a sweet pie of your choice - 6 Month Pie of The Month Club

How it works: 1. Place your order by selecting a 3, 6, or 12 Month membership 2. Select the date and time you'd like to pick up your certificates 3. A member of our team will have your certificates ready at our pickup counter 4. Stop by anytime through the month to redeem your certificate for a sweet pie of your choice - 12 Month Pie of The Month Club

“Southern Baked” is a custom blend exclusively for Southern Baked Pie that smells just like walking into our *sweet* pie shops. It is the perfect blend of almond, cream, sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, coconut and tonka bean. “Georgia” is fresh and clean with a citrus base and a hint of peach. "Frasier Fir" is light and fresh and lacks any fake pine scent. Candles made by Southern Bungalow Co. Each candle is hand poured using an eco-friendly coconut wax, essential oils and phthalate free fragrance oils. Coconut wax burns clean, burns slowly and has a superior scent throw.The white ceramic containers have an organic uneven rim; no two are alike. Each 12 oz. candle has a 60+ hour burn time. Southern Bungalow Co. was created from a love for fragrances and all things beautiful for the home. Each Southern Bungalow candle is hand poured in a reusable statement piece for your home and is crafted in small batches to insure that every detail is perfect. - Southern Baked

“Southern Baked” is a custom blend exclusively for Southern Baked Pie that smells just like walking into our *sweet* pie shops. It is the perfect blend of almond, cream, sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, coconut and tonka bean. “Georgia” is fresh and clean with a citrus base and a hint of peach. "Frasier Fir" is light and fresh and lacks any fake pine scent. Candles made by Southern Bungalow Co. Each candle is hand poured using an eco-friendly coconut wax, essential oils and phthalate free fragrance oils. Coconut wax burns clean, burns slowly and has a superior scent throw.The white ceramic containers have an organic uneven rim; no two are alike. Each 12 oz. candle has a 60+ hour burn time. Southern Bungalow Co. was created from a love for fragrances and all things beautiful for the home. Each Southern Bungalow candle is hand poured in a reusable statement piece for your home and is crafted in small batches to insure that every detail is perfect. - Georgia

Pint

Salted & Roasted Pecans

Chocolate Amaretto Pecans

1/2lb Salted Caramel Popcorn

1/2 lb Birthday Cake Popcorn

Pint of High Road Vanilla ice cream - perfect on top of our delicious pies! - Pint

Slices the pie into 8 perfectly uniform slices. - Regular

Marks your pie to have 8 uniform slices. - Regular

Reusable pie server. - Regular