Ritter's Frozen Custard

4840 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Hours of Service:

Monday: 11:00am - 9:00pm

Tuesday: 11:00am - 9:00pm

Wednesday: 11:00am - 9:00pm

Thursday: 11:00am - 9:00pm

Friday: 11:00am - 10:00pm

Saturday: 11:00am - 10:00pm

Sunday: 12:00pm - 9:00pm

(Hours of Service May Vary)
Party Sheet Cake

full sheet serves 25 to 30, half sheet serves 12 to 15, quarter sheet serves 3 to 5. its not a party until the ritter's cake shows up, its a delicious layer of our chocolate or vanilla frozen custard on a moist chocolate or white cake.

Party Round Cake

serves 10 to 12. let the party begin two layers of chocolate or vanilla frozen custard between chocolate or vanilla cake. you pick the perfect combination, and we'll surround it with whipped icing

Torte-style Cake

serves 10 to 12. two delicate layers of chocolate or vanilla frozen custard between moist chocolate or vanilla cake.


serves 10 to 12. moist chocolate or vanilla cake layered with your choice of frozen custard flavor(s). go ahead. have it your way. additional charges may apply.

Banana Split Cake

serves 10 to 12. white and chocolate cake, layered with fresh banana frozen custard, strawberries, and pineapple, chocolate syrup, butter toasted pecans, and cherries for real a-peel.

Heath Bar Cake

serves 10 to 12. moist white cake layered with vanilla frozen custard and crumbled heath bars, and our own caramel and chocolate syrup toppings. evidently decadence has a new name

Oreo Cookie Cake

serves 10 to 12. moist chocolate cake and vanilla frozen custard separated by layers of real oreos. surrounded by whipped icing and topped with yet more oreos.

Rese's Cake

serves 10 to 12. three tastes in one. moist chocolate cake layered with vanilla frozen custard and crumbled reeses cups topped with real peanut butter sauce. you'll be nuts over it

Mint Chocolate Chip Pie

serves 10 to 12. oreo cookie crust with mint chocolate chip frozen custard, hot fudge, marshmallow cream, and chocolate curls

Mud Pie

serves 10 to 12. oreo cookie crust and chocolate frozen custard with chocolate syrup, marshmallow cream, and crushed oreos with a cherry on top.

Peanut Butter Mountain Pie

serves 10 to 12. oreo cookie crust and vanilla frozen custard piled high with ground reese's cups, peanut butter sauce, and chocolate syrup

Snicker's Pie

serves 10 to 12. oreo cookie crust with vanilla frozen custard smothered with hot fudge, caramel topping, and ground snickers.

Turtle Pie

serves 10 to 12. oreo cookie and vanilla frozen custard with hot fudge and caramel topping and butter toasted peanuts

Our Flavors Of Perfection

at ritter's, we're always creating a fresh batch of frozen custard. so our flavour menu is always changing. but there are some constants. we'll always have vanila. we'll always have chocolate. we'll always have a lite, nut, and fruit speciality and a fruit flavour. and whichever flavour you choose, whether its for a cone, a shake, a glacier, or a sundae, it will always be legendary

Cones And Dishes

smooth and creamy frozen custard with fresh ingredients. not your everyday treat. unless of course, you want it to be. small (1 scoop), regular (2 scoops), large (3 scoops)


start with our legendary frozen custard. then add one, two, even three of our terrific toppings. small- 1 scoop, regular- 2 scoops, large- 3 scoops


as famous for their thickness as they are for their taste, our glaciers combine delectable frozen custard with your favorite toppings. always served the right way--upside down. small, regular, large

Shakes And Malts

there's baseball. there's apple pie. and then there's the real, old-fashioned milkshake. hand-dipped legendary ice cream, whole milk, and rich toppings. whirled together by a classic milk shake machine. we'd be happy to whip you up one or two or three or just pick your size and flavour. regular, large

Turtle Sundae

sure to bring you of your shell. frozen custard, smothered in hot fudge and hot caramel sauce topped with whipped cream, butter toasted pecans, and yes, a cherry

Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae

also known as the best of all worlds. a rich brownie nestled between scoops of frozen custard, drizzled with hot fudge, topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

Strawberry Delight

it's the berries. our legendary frozen custard, with fresh strawberries, crispy wafer cookies, real whipped cream, and a cherry.

Grizzly Cub

take our oh so - creamy frozen custard . layer it with milk thick, rich, hot fudge sauce and spinach peanuts. it's dessert you'll want to get your paws on

Peanut Butter Mountain

legendary frozen custard. creamy peanut butter topping. reese's peanut butter cups. real whipped cream and a cherry. it's yours to conquer.

Mud Sundae

attention chocolate lovers! your dessert has arrived. chocolate frozen custard, chocolate syrup, a dollop of marshmallow, real whipped cream, crushed oreos, and naturally, a cherry.

The Classic Bannana Split

a fresh banana, scoops of ritter's frozen custard, rich chocolate syrup, and fresh strawberry and pineapple. add in real whipped cream, crispy butter toasted pecans, and a festive cherry. who wouldn't go bananas

Cappuccino Smoothies

perk things up with frozen custard blended with slow roasted, premium coffee. sweeten the deal with chocolate or caramel syrup.

Real Fruit Smoothies

frozen custard blended with real fruit purees for a berry, berry good treat. there's even a non-dairy options

Frozen Custard Floats

take your favorite coca-cola flavor, diet or regular. add a scoop or two of our rich, creamy frozen custard. voila. a classic treat with a legendary twist.

Lemon Shake-ups

for those days when our fresh, creamy ice cream just won't hit the spot, we present a refreshing alternative. lemon shake-ups made with fresh-squeezed lemons. regular / large

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0
© 2021 BringMeThat, Inc