Bring_me_that_logo

Sanibel Seafood Company - Noblesville, IN

15009 Gray Rd, Noblesville, IN 46062
IN > Noblesville > 46062
Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Soup

Soup

Bowl (16 oz)

$6.88

Sides

Fries

$2.75
Mac and Cheese

$2.75
Slaw

$2.75
Baked Potato

$2.75
Green Beans

$2.75
Collard Greens

$2.75

Cold Sandwiches

Order Mom's Chicken Salad Sandwich food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Mom's Chicken Salad Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$11.00
Italian Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$11.00
Mom's Tuna Salad Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$11.00
Clubhouse Wrap

Choice of 1 side.

$11.00
M.Y.O Sandwich

Turkey, ham, or roast beef. Choice of 1 side.

$11.00

Starters

Order Clam Chowder food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Clam Chowder

$6.88
Fire Shrimp

20 pieces.

$9.62
Crab Cake

5 oz. 1 piece cake.

$9.62

Sandwiches

Order Sanibel Sandwich food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Sanibel Sandwich

A mild white fish. Choice of 1 side.

$12.38
Fish Taco Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$15.12
Shrimp Taco Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$15.12
Tilapia Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$12.38
Cod Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$13.75
Salmon Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$13.75
Grouper Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$20.62
Shrimp Po Boy

Choice of 1 side.

$13.75
Lobster Roll Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$23.38

Hot Sandwiches

Order Reuben Sandwich food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Reuben Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$15.12
Rib Eye Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$13.75
Cheeseburger

Choice of 1 side.

$12.38
Ham and Swiss Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$15.12
Pastrami on Rye Sandwich

Choice of 1 side.

$15.12

Salads

Chopped Salad

$9.62
Wedge Salad

$9.62

Beverages

Drinks

$1.38

Baskets

Order Fish and Shrimp Basket food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Fish and Shrimp Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$15.12
Order Fish and Chips Basket food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Fish and Chips Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$16.50
Order Salmon Basket food online from Sanibel Seafood Company store, Noblesville on bringmethat.com
Salmon Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$17.88
Sanibel Basket

A mild white fish. Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$13.75
Lake Perch Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$17.88
Tilapia Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$13.75
Grouper Basket

Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$26.12
Fried Shrimp Basket

40 pieces. Choice of 1 side and 2 hush puppies.

$17.88
Kids Meal Basket

Fish sticks or grilled cheese. Served with fries and drink.

$8.25

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews