OddFellow Ice Cream Co. - Newton, MA

16oz blended milkshake made using your choice of ice cream flavor(s) and milk. Check out our "tubs" menu for allergens on particular flavors.

Choose as many tubs as you like, and round out your party pack with any of our toppings to complement them! Priced accordingly by item.

Dark Chocolate Chunk and Vanilla Bean ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs

Dark Chocolate Chunk, Vanilla Bean, and Strawberry Jam ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs

Strawberry Jam ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs

Sweet Cream & Sprinkles ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in rainbow sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs

Peanut Butter and Jelly ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, peanuts

Sweet cream and sprinkles ice cream, sandwiched between two chocolate cookie wafers and rolled in tons of rainbow sprinkles!

Lamington (or chocolate coconut cake) ice cream with raspberry jam, sandwiched between two chocolate wafer cookies and rolled in vanilla cookie pieces.

Chewy chocolate chip cookies with your choice of ice cream in the middle (a kid's-sized scoop), rolled in your choice of crunchy topping! Note: cookies are made at a separate facility and may contain traces of peanuts/tree nuts. Contains gluten/dairy.

Different soda varieties

10" ice cream cake made with our peanut butter s'mores ice cream and finished with chocolate cookie crumble, chocolate fudge frosting and marshmallows.

Sweet cream vanilla base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)

Sweet cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)

Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)

Dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG)

Strawberry sweet cream base with ribbons of Oregon strawberry jam. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY)

Sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. (ALLERGENS, DAIRY, EGG, GLUTEN)

Sorbet with mango, guava, passionfruit, and banana

Peanut butter ice cream with streaks of grape jelly. (ALLERGENS: DIARY, EGG, PEANUT)

Coconut milk ice cram base with chocolate chips and streaks of caramel.

Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate chips, and marshmallow. (ALLERGENS: DAIRY, EGG, PEANUT, GLUTEN)

Part of our PenguinRandomhouse BrainFreeze collab. Bubblegum flavored ice cream with bright pink sprinkles. Allergens: Dairy, egg.

Part of our PenguinRandomhouse BrainFreeze collab. Cinnamon miso ice cream with caramel swirl. Allergens: Dairy, egg, soy.

Blood orange and vanilla ice cream. Allergens: dairy, egg.

Butter pecan ice cream with swirls of peanut butter and chopped pecans. Allergens: dairy, egg, peanut, pecan.

Sweet Cream ice cream with chocolate covered potato chips, everything sticks, white chocolate chips and chocolate chip cookie dough. Allergens: dairy, egg, gluten, sesame. (May contain tree nuts.)

Smooth and creamy malted banana ice cream. Allergens: dairy, egg.

A malted chocolate milk ice cream, with globs of thick fudge and chunks of fudgy brownies. Allergens: Dairy, Gluten, Egg

A banana ice cream with swirls of rich dulce de leche and graham cracker crust crumbled in. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten

A beautiful blackberry ice cream with swirls of bright raspberry jam. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs

Maple Ice cream packed with a mix of chocolate cookie crumbs, mini marshmallows, M&M's, Sno-Caps and corn nuts. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs, Gluten, Gelatin

A spiced eggnog ice cream with swirls of fudge and peanut butter cups. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs, Nuts

Cashew-based mint chocolate ice cream with chunks of chocolate cookies. Contains: Cashew, Gluten