Bring_me_that_logo

Baldwin Bagel Cafe - Baldwin, NY

2162 Grand Avenue, Baldwin, NY 11510
NY > Baldwin > 11510
Pickup
|
Delivery






Main Menu

Beverages

Order Fountain Drink (24 oz) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Fountain Drink (24 oz)

$9.00
Order Fountain Drink (32oz.) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Fountain Drink (32oz.)

Please Choose: Iced Tea or Pink Lemonade

$10.38
Bottle of Soda (20oz.)

$5.62
Gatorade (20oz)

$5.62
Poland Spring Water Bottle

$4.88
Red Bull

$6.88
Snapple

$5.62
Nesquik

Please Specify Flavor: Chocolate or Strawberry

$5.62
Yoo-Hoo Bottle

$5.62
Tropicana Juice (12 oz)

Please Specify: Orange, Apple or Cranberry

$5.62
Tropicana Quart OJ

$6.88
1/2 Gallon Regular Milk

$8.25

Bagels "Individual Pieces" Please Do Not add Toppings

Order Bagels food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Bagels

Individual Bagel! Please DO NOT add any Toppings.

$3.12
Order Assorted Dozen food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Assorted Dozen

$35.75
Order Flat Bagels food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Flat Bagels

$4.12

Coffee

Order Hot Coffee (16 oz) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Hot Coffee (16 oz)

$5.88
Order Iced Coffee (24 oz) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Iced Coffee (24 oz)

$9.00
Order Iced Coffee (32oz.) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Iced Coffee (32oz.)

$10.38
Box of Coffee (10-14 cups)

$45.38

Sandwich Suggestions

Order Novalicious food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Novalicious

Sliced Nova, Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomatoes, Red Onion and Cucumber. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$27.50
Order Whitefish Salad on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Whitefish Salad on a Bagel

Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$26.12
Order Baked Salmon Salad on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Baked Salmon Salad on a Bagel

Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$26.12
Order Any Salad Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Any Salad Sandwich

Please Choose any: Tuna, Egg Salad or Chicken Salad. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$20.62
Order Build Your Own Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Build Your Own Sandwich

Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$20.62
Order BLT Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
BLT Sandwich

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$17.88
Order Chicken or Turkey Time Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chicken or Turkey Time Sandwich

Your choice of either Turkey or any Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order Americana Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Americana Sandwich

Ham, turkey, roast beef, American and Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and coleslaw. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order The Soprano Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
The Soprano Sandwich

Ham capicola, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, and oil and vinegar. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order Chicken Tuscany Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chicken Tuscany Sandwich

Grilled or fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, red onions, and housemade balsamic. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order Big Bird Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Big Bird Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order Bubbalicious Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Bubbalicious Sandwich

Fried chicken cutlets, melted mozzarella, bacon, and spicy BBQ sauce. Includes a pickle and LIBC famous macaroni salad.

$23.38
Order Buffalo Bill Sandwich food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Buffalo Bill Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, hot sauce, lettuces, and blue cheese dressing. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38
Order The Reuben food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
The Reuben

Hot Pastrami, Turkey or Corn Beef melted Swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing. Served with a pickle and a side salad of your choice.

$23.38
Roast Beef or Turkey Royale Sandwich

Choice of Hot Roast Beef or Turkey with melted mozzarella on garlic bread. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$23.38

Miscellaneous

Order Rice Pudding with Whip Cream food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Rice Pudding with Whip Cream

$9.62
Order Chocolate Parfait Cup food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Parfait Cup

$9.62
Order Fruit Cup food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Fruit Cup

$9.62
Yogurt Parfait with Granola

$9.62

Appy's

Order Hand Carved Nova Scotia Lox (1/4 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Hand Carved Nova Scotia Lox (1/4 LB)

$33.00
Order Chunky White Fish Salad (1/2 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chunky White Fish Salad (1/2 LB)

$26.12
Order Chunky Baked Salmon Salad (1/2 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chunky Baked Salmon Salad (1/2 LB)

$26.12
Order Classic Tuna Salad (1/2 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Classic Tuna Salad (1/2 LB)

$17.25
Order Chicken Salad (1/2 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chicken Salad (1/2 LB)

$17.25
Order Sliced Cold Cuts by the 1/2 Lb food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Sliced Cold Cuts by the 1/2 Lb

$13.75
Order Sliced Cheese by the 1/2 LB food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Sliced Cheese by the 1/2 LB

$12.38
Order Fried or Grilled Chicken Cutlets (1 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Fried or Grilled Chicken Cutlets (1 LB)

$22.00
Egg Salad (1/2 LB)

$16.50

Side Salads

Order Macaroni Salad (1 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Macaroni Salad (1 LB)

$12.38
Order Potato Salad (1 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Potato Salad (1 LB)

$12.38
Order Coleslaw (1 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Coleslaw (1 LB)

$12.38
Order Pasta Primavera (1 LB) food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Pasta Primavera (1 LB)

$12.38

HARD TO FIND ESSENTIALS: Due to unexpected and unfortunate times we would like to use our platform to help the community get these hard to find items.

1/2 Gallon Regular Milk

$8.25
Tropicana Quart OJ

$6.88
5x6 Tomato (1pc)

$4.12
Head of Iceberg Lettuce (1pc)

$6.88
Roll of Toilet Paper

$2.75
Roll of Paper Towels

$4.12

Hot Breakfast from the Grill

Order 2 Eggs on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
2 Eggs on a Bagel

$8.25
Order 2 Eggs with Meat food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
2 Eggs with Meat

$11.00
Order Heart Attack Hero food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Heart Attack Hero

3 eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a hero.

$15.12
Order Challah French Toast food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Challah French Toast

Served with a side of Butter, Syrup and a dusting of powdered sugar.

$12.38
2 Eggs Whites

$8.25
2 Egg Whites with Meat

$11.00
Leo

Lox, eggs, and onion.

$15.12
Stack of Pancakes

3 Buttermilk Pancakes served with a side of Butter and Syrup

$12.38

Breakfast Wraps

Order Breakfast Wrap 1 food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Breakfast Wrap 1

3 Egg Whites, Spinach, Mushrooms, and Broccoli

$12.38
Order Breakfast Wrap 4 food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Breakfast Wrap 4

3 Egg Whites, Pepper Turkey, Ham, Peppers, Onions, and Hot Sauce

$13.12
Order Breakfast Wrap 6 food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Breakfast Wrap 6

6 Egg Whites and Grilled Chicken with Jalapenos and Cheddar Cheese

$15.12
Breakfast Wrap 3

3 Egg Whites, Sliced Lox, and Caramelized Onions

$15.12

Bakery Department

Order Muffins food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Muffins

$6.25
Order Apple Turnover food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Apple Turnover

$6.25
Order Chocolate Cigar food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Chocolate Cigar

$6.25
Order Black and White Cookie food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Black and White Cookie

$6.25

Wraps

Order Caesar's Revenge Wrap food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Caesar's Revenge Wrap

Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, and Caesar dressing. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75
Order The Sailor food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
The Sailor

Grilled Chicken or Honey Mustard Chicken Salad with lettuce, tomato and Honey Mustard dressing. Served with a pickle and a side salad of your choice.

$22.75
Order The Oceansider food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
The Oceansider

Turkey Breast, Alpine Lace Swiss, Avocado and coleslaw on your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75
Jillian's Delight Wrap

Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, and melted mozzarella with balsamic. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75
Santa Fe Pepper Turkey Wrap

Roasted peppers and grilled onions with spicy jalapeno mayonnaise. Includes a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75
Any Chicken Salad Wrap

Your choice of Chicken Salad with lettuce and tomato in your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75
Any Tuna Salad on a Wrap

Your choice of Tuna with lettuce and tomato on your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.

$22.75

Breakfast Spreads by the 1/2 LB

Order 1/2 LB Plain Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Plain Cream Cheese

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$12.38
Order 1/2 LB Vegetable Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Vegetable Cream Cheese

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$13.12
Order 1/2 LB Scallion Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Scallion Cream Cheese

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$13.12
Order 1/2 LB Lox Spread food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Lox Spread

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$14.50
Order 1/2 LB Olive Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Olive Cream Cheese

$13.12
Order 1/2 LB Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese

$13.75
Order 1/2 LB Sundried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Sundried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$13.75
Order 1/2 LB Strawberry Cream Cheese food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
1/2 LB Strawberry Cream Cheese

$13.75
1/2 LB Butter

$11.75

Breakfast Spreads on a Bagel

Order Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$6.25
Order Vegetable Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Vegetable Cream Cheese on a Bagel

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$9.62
Order Scallion Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Scallion Cream Cheese on a Bagel

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$9.62
Order Lox Spread on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Lox Spread on a Bagel

Please Specify Regular or Lowfat

$11.00
Order Olive Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Olive Cream Cheese on a Bagel

$9.62
Order Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese on a Bagel

$9.62
Order Sundried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese on a Bagel food online from Baldwin Bagel Cafe store, Baldwin on bringmethat.com
Sundried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese on a Bagel

$9.62
Butter on a Bagel

$5.88

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews