Bring_me_that_logo

John's Pizza & Subs - Grand Island, NY

2131 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, NY 14072
NY > Grand Island > 14072
Pickup
|
Delivery






Popular Items

ONION RINGS

$5.36
2 SLICE PIZZA & DRINK

2 Slices Cheese & Pepperoni and a Medium Beverage

$7.61
SLICE CHEESE & PEPPERONI

$3.75
COLD CUT SUB PLATTER

$60.99
LARGE FOUNTAIN PEPSI

$3.36
Steak & Cheese

A Customer Favorite! Tender Rib-Eye Steak with melted Swiss American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.22 +
Chicken Finger Sub

It's now an Institution, Our Famous Chicken Fingers shaken in our Tangy Hot Sauce with Lettuce, Tomato, Provolone Cheese, then smothered with Blue Cheese. Copied the world over yet still the original and the best....since 1982!

$10.11 +
GREEK SALAD

Fresh Crisp Salad Greens with Chicken or Steak, Green & Black Olives, Hot or Sweet Peppers, Eggs, Cucumber & Tomato

$7.49 +

Main Menu

Pizza

Build your own

$9.62 +
SLICE CHEESE PIZZA

$3.19
SLICE CHEESE & PEPPERONI

$3.75
Gourmet slice of the week

$3.75

Gourmet Pizza

CHICKEN FINGER PIZZA

$14.11 +
STEAK PIZZA

$14.11 +
STINGER PIZZA

$14.86 +
WHITE PIZZA

$14.11
HOUSE COMBO PIZZA

$14.11
JOHN'S BIG MACK PIZZA

$14.11
SPINACH & TOMATO PIZZA

$14.11 +
MEATEATERS PIZZA

$14.11
RODEO BURGER PIZZA

$14.11
TACO PIZZA

$14.11 +

SPECIALTY SUBS

Sub Of The Month Sweet Chili Chicken Finger Sub

Golden Chicken Fingers with Franks Sweet Chili Sauce, Kraft Blue Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$10.11 +
Order Chicken Finger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Finger Sub

It's now an Institution, Our Famous Chicken Fingers shaken in our Tangy Hot Sauce with Lettuce, Tomato, Provolone Cheese, then smothered with Blue Cheese. Copied the world over yet still the original and the best....since 1982!

$10.11 +
Western

Made with Plump Juicy Chicken Fingers, Smothered with our delicious BBQ Sauce, topped with American Cheese. All served on a toasted roll with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo.

$10.11 +
CHICKEN CLUB SUB

Tyson Chicken Fingers with Ranch Dressing, Lettuce, Tomato and Crispy Bacon

$10.49 +
Order Steak Hoagie food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Steak Hoagie

Loaded with Tender Rib Eye Steak, Sauteed Onions, Mushrooms and your choice of Hot, Sweet or Green Peppers then topped with Melted Cheese.

$13.74 +
SAUSAGE HOAGIE

Italian Sausage, Choice of Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions & Mozzarella Cheese

$9.86 +
STINGER

A Mouthful of Juicy Rib Eye Steak & Tender Chicken Fingers, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.36 +
STEAK & RING SUB

Our Steak Sub Covered with Onion Rings & Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato-Baked to Perfection

$10.11 +
GODFATHER

Thinly Sliced Ham & Capicola piled high, Baked with Pepperoni & Provolone Cheese then topped with Lettuce & Tomato

$9.36 +
Order Chicken Finger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Finger Sub

It's now an Institution, Our Famous Chicken Fingers shaken in our Tangy Hot Sauce with Lettuce, Tomato, Provolone Cheese, then smothered with Blue Cheese. Copied the world over yet still the original and the best....since 1982!

$13.99 +
Order The Nightmare food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
The Nightmare

Rib Eye Steak, Italian Sausage, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese

$14.99 +
Order Italian Sausage Hoagie food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Italian Sausage Hoagie

An American favorite: Italian Sausage, Fried Green Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms then topped with American Cheese and baked to Perfection.

$13.74 +
Order Chicken Hoagie food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Hoagie

Grilled Chicken Tenderloin, Sauteed Onions, Mushrooms and your choice of Hot, Banana or Green Peppers then topped with Mozzarella Cheese then Baked to Perfection.

$13.74 +
Order Chicken in the Grass Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken in the Grass Sub

Grilled Chicken, Fresh Spinach, your choice of Dressing, baked with Provolone Cheese then topped with Lettuce & Tomato.

$14.36 +
Order Steak in the Grass Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Steak in the Grass Sub

Chopped Rib Eye Steak, Fresh Spinach, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese topped with your choice of dressing and baked to perfection.

$14.36 +
Order Steak-N-Ring Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Steak-N-Ring Sub

Out Delicious Steak & Cheese Sub topped with Golden Brown Onion Rings & Smothered with Mozzarella Cheese.

$14.36 +
Order The Godfather Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
The Godfather Sub

Thinly Sliced Ham & Capicola piled high, baked with Pepperoni & Provolone Cheese then topped with Lettuce & Tomato

$13.06 +
Order Steak-N-Ring Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Steak-N-Ring Sub

Out Delicious Steak & Cheese Sub topped with Golden Brown Onion Rings & Smothered with Mozzarella Cheese.

$14.36 +
Order Beef on Weck Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Beef on Weck Sub

Our amazing Roast Beef with a Horseradish Mayo on our own Kimmelweck Sub Roll with Lettuce, Tomato and Provolone Cheese!

$14.36 +
Order *--*---------------- food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
*--*----------------

Thinly Sliced Ham & Capicola piled high, baked with Pepperoni & Provolone Cheese then topped with Lettuce & Tomato

$14.36 +

SUBS

RIB EYE STEAK & CHEESE

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$7.74 +
PHILLY CHICKEN STEAK

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$7.11 +
ROYAL

Italian Sausage & Capicola on a Toasted Roll with Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & your Choice of Dressing

$7.74 +
ITALIAN SAUSAGE

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese &Choice of Dressing

$7.11 +
CHICKEN PARMESAN

Chicken Tenders, Sauce & Cheese Baked to Perfection

$8.61 +
CHEESE BURGER

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$7.74 +
BACON CHEESE BURGER

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$9.06 +
PIZZA SUB

Old School Pizza Sub Add Toppings of Your Choice

$6.24 +
MEATBALL

Baked with Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese

$7.74 +
BAKED CHEESE

5 Cheese Baked with Lettuce, Tomato & Choice of Dressing

$6.24 +
FRIED BOLOGNA

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.24 +
BACON, LETTUCE & TOMATO

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato on a Toasted Roll, Choice of Dressing

$6.19 +
ROAST BEEF

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato on a Toasted Roll, Choice of Dressing

$7.74 +
ASSORTED

Toasted Roll, Ham, Capicola, Salami & Bologna, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese with Choice of Dressing

$6.86 +
TURKEY

Oven roasted Turkey on a Toasted Roll, lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.99 +
TURKEY CLUB

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$8.11 +
HAM & CHEESE

Thinly Sliced Ham on a Toasted Roll with Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.86 +
CAPICOLA

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.86 +
TUNA

Fresh Tuna on a Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.99 +
SALAMI

Toasted Roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$6.86 +
HERCULES

A Toasted Roll with Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham with Lettuce. Tomato and Provolone Cheese

$7.74 +
ITALIAN DELIGHT

Our Version of an Italian Parmesan with our Special Sauce to make it Truly Unique

$7.74 +
ULTIMATE VEGGIE SUB

Loaded with Veggies, Lettuce, Tomato, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Black Olives covered in Mozzarella and Baked to Perfection!

$6.24 +
FISH SUB

Golden Filet of Cod with Lettuce, Tomato, American Cheese & Tarter Sauce

$7.74 +

Wings

WINGS 10 - 20 - 30 - 50

Served with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrots

$14.36 +
BONELESS WINGS 10 - 20 - 30 - 50

Chicken without the bone served with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrots

$14.36 +
CHICKEN FINGERS with FRIES

Golden Chicken Fingers Served with Blue Cheese, Celery, Carrots & Fries

$14.24 +
CHICKEN FINGERS 20 or 30

Served with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrots

$37.49 +
INDIVIDUAL FINGER

Just to snack on A Golden Finger all by its Lonesome

$2.61

Salad

CHEF SALAD

$4.49 +
ANTIPASTO

A Mix of Meats, Cheeses & Fresh Salad Greens

$7.74 +
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD

Fresh Salad Greens, Tender Chicken Fingers tossed in Franks Hot Sauce

$12.36
APPLE ALMOND GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD

A Fresh Bed of Salad Greens, Tomato, Cucumbers, Diced Apple, Feta Cheese, Sliver Almond & Craisins covered with Tender Strips of Char-Broiled Chicken Breast. We recomed a Balsamic or Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing

$6.36 +
GREEK SALAD

Fresh Crisp Salad Greens with Chicken or Steak, Green & Black Olives, Hot or Sweet Peppers, Eggs, Cucumber & Tomato

$7.49 +
JULIENNE

A Fresh Bed of salad Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Eggs Topped with Jack Cheese Ham & Turkey

$6.11 +
CHICKEN TACO SALAD

Grilled Chicken in a Crisp Floured Shell with Lettuce, Tomato, Jack Cheese, Black Olives, Choice of Peppers Salsa & Sour Cream

$11.36
TACO SALAD

A Crisp Floured Shell Filled with our Fresh Taco Meat, Lettuce, Tomato, Jack Cheese, Black Olives, Hot or Sweet Peppers, Salsa & Sour Cream

$11.24

Tacos and Wraps

BEEF TACO

John's Seasoned Fresh Ground Beef, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese

$7.24
TUNA WRAP

Fresh Tuna, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese

$6.99
BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP

Crispy Chicken Fingers Shaken in Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese

$8.86
GRILLED CHICKEN WRAP

Grilled Chicken Tenderloin with Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$7.24
GREEK WRAP

Grilled Chicken or Steak, Feta Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Black Olives & Greek Dressing

$8.86
STINGER WRAP

Rib Eye Steak & Tender Chicken Fingers Shaken in Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese

$11.49
FISH TACO

Crispy Icelandic Cod, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Creamy Tarter

$7.49

Something Else

FISH DINNER

Beer Battered Haddock served with Cole Slaw, Fries & Garlic Bread

$17.49
BEEF ON WECK w/FRIES

Over a Quarter Pound of Thinly Sliced Beef dipped in Au Jus served on a Toasted Kimmelweck with Fries & a Pickle

$10.36
SOUP - Buffalo Chicken Wing

$4.98

Sides

ONION RINGS

$5.36
FRENCH FRIES

$3.61
CURLY Q

$3.86
BUFFALO BREAD

Garlic Bread Topped with Diced Chicken Fingers Shaken in Hot Sauce with Blue Cheese & Mozzarella Cheese

$10.49
SMALL CHEESY GARLIC STICKS

Delicious Garlic Sticks served with Marinara Sauce

$3.61
MOZZARELLA STICKS

$7.86
PIZZA LOGS

$9.11
BARBECUED PIZZA LOGS

$9.61
PICK 4 SAMPLE PLATTER

(choose 4)

$18.36
POPPERS

$8.61
GOUDA MAC CHEESE BITES

Gouda Mac & Cheese Bites Served with BBQ Sauce or Ranch Dressing

$8.61
FRIED PICKLE CHIPS with Ranch Dipping Sauce

$7.36
CHIPS

$1.81
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE

$1.81
ICE CREAM

$5.31
APPLE GRANNY LOGS with Glazed Dipping Sauce

$7.36
CHEESY GARLIC STICKS

Delicious Garlic Sticks served with Marinara Sauce

$6.11

Beverages

LARGE FOUNTAIN PEPSI

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN PEPSI

$2.74
20 OZ BOTTLE PEPSI

$3.06
2-LITER PEPSI

$3.74
LARGE FOUNTAIN DIET PEPSI

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN DIET PEPSI

$2.74
20 OZ BOTTLE DIET PEPSI

$3.06
2-LITER DIET PEPSI

$3.74
LARGE FOUNTAIN DR PEPPER

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN DR PEPPER

$2.74
20 OZ BOTTLE DR PEPPER

$2.74
2-LTR DR PEPPER

$3.74
LARGE FOUNTAIN MNT DEW

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN MNT DEW

$2.74
20 OZ BOTTLE MNT DEW

$3.06
2 LTR MNT DEW

$3.74
LARGE FOUNTAIN SIERRA MIST

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN SIERRA MIST

$2.74
2-LITER SIERRA MIST

$3.74
LARGE FOUNTAIN BRISK ICED TEA

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN BRISK ICED TEA

$2.74
20 OZ BOTTLE BRISK ICED TEA

$3.06
LARGE FOUNTAIN LOGAN

$3.36
MEDIUM FOUNTAIN LOGAN

$2.74
COFFEE

$2.24
BOTTLE WATER

$2.31
AMP

$3.74
20 OZ BOTTLE MUG ROOTBEER

$3.06
LIFE WATER

$3.06
GATORADE

$3.06

Combo

2 SLICE PIZZA & DRINK

2 Slices Cheese & Pepperoni and a Medium Beverage

$7.61

Party Ideas

SUB PLATTER

5 Cold Cut Subs Cut into 20 Sandwiches Displayed on a Domed Tray. Served with a Side of Hot & Banana Peppers & Condiments on the side. Serves 12-16

$60.99
JOHNS SUB PLATTER

$60.99
BUFFALO CHICKEN FINGER SUB PLATTER

$69.61
COLD CUT SUB PLATTER

$60.99
BEEF ON WECK PLATTER

10 Roast Beef on Kimmelweck Rolls cut in half and served on a Domed Tray

$73.49
BUFFALO WRAP PLATTER

$73.49
ASSORTED WRAP PLATTER

$70.86

CHICKEN FINGER SUBS

Order The Western Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
The Western Sub

Made with Plump Juicy Chicken Fingers, Smothered with our delicious BBQ Sauce, topped with American Cheese. All served on a toasted roll with lettuce, Tomato & Mayo.

$15.24 +
Order Chicken Finger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Finger Sub

$15.24 +
Order Sweet Chili Chicken Finger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Sweet Chili Chicken Finger Sub

With Frank's Sweet Chili Sauce, Kraft Blue Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$15.24 +
Order Chicken Finger Pizza Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Finger Pizza Sub

Our Delicious Chicken Finger Pizza Now as a Sub. Our homemade Buffalo Sauce with diced Chicken Fingers, Celery and Mozzarella Cheese and Baked to Perfection.

$11.56 +
Veggie Chicken Fingers Sub

Vegetarian Breaded Chik'n Patties Tossed in Tangy Hot Sauce with Lettuce, Tomato, Provolone Cheese, then Smothered with Kraft Blue Cheese

$15.24 +
Order Stinger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Stinger Sub

A Mouthful of Juicy Rib Eye Steak & Tender Chicken Fingers, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato.

$16.11 +

PARMESAN SUBS

Order Chicken Parmesan Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Parmesan Sub

Our Breaded Chicken Fingers with Spaghetti Sauce then covered in Melted Sorrento Mozzarella.

$13.49 +
Order John's Italian Delight Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
John's Italian Delight Sub

Our version of a Sausage Parmesan in Our Original Sauce and Topped off with Mozzarella then Baked.

$10.81 +
Order Meatball Parmesan Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Meatball Parmesan Sub

Plump meatballs in our Spaghetti Sauce Covered with loads of Mozzarella then Baked To Perfection!

$10.81 +
Order Pizza Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Pizza Sub

Mozzarella cheese, Pizza sauce and your choice of toppings baked to perfection.

$11.56 +
Order ------------ food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
------------

Our Breaded Chicken Fingers with Spaghetti Sauce then covered in Melted Sorrento Mozzarella.

$10.81 +

HOT SUBS

Order Steak & Cheese food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Steak & Cheese

A Customer Favorite! Tender Rib-Eye Steak with melted Swiss American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.22 +
Order Royal Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Royal Sub

A Great Combo of Italian Sausage & Capicola with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$11.22 +
Order Italian Sausage Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Italian Sausage Sub

Mild Sausage Patties with Provolone Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$9.94 +
Order Cheeseburger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Cheeseburger Sub

Juicy Cloud Burgers with Provolone & American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.22 +
Order Bacon Cheeseburger Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

Our Delicious Cheeseburger Sub made even better with Bacon

$13.10 +
Order Fried Bologna & Onion Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Fried Bologna & Onion Sub

Over 1/3 pound of Thinly Sliced Charred Bologna with Grilled Onions, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$9.69 +
Order Chicken Philly Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Chicken Philly Sub

Grilled Chicken finely chopped & smothered with Swiss American Cheese on top of Lettuce & Tomato

$9.94 +
Order Fish Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Fish Sub

Beer Battered Haddock with Tartar Sauce, American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.22 +
Order Baked Cheese Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Baked Cheese Sub

Five Cheeses Melted to perfection with Lettuce & Tomato

$9.69 +
Order Ultimate Veggie Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Ultimate Veggie Sub

The Whole Garden on one sub! Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Green Peppers with Melted Mozzarella Cheese

$9.69 +

COLD CUT SUBS

Order Ham & Cheese Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Ham & Cheese Sub

Ham with Provolone Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$9.06 +
Order Turkey Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Turkey Sub

Turkey piled high with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$11.06 +
Order Assorted food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Assorted

A blend of mouth watering cold cuts...Ham, Bologna, Salami,and Capicola lettuce tomato and provolone cheese!

$10.31 +
Order Hercules food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Hercules

Over a third of a pound thinly sliced ham & turkey piled high on your choice of sub roll.

$11.11 +
Order Roast Beef Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Roast Beef Sub

Tender Roast Beef with Provolone Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$11.36 +
Order Capicola Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Capicola Sub

Delicious Capicola with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$10.31 +
Order Salami Sub food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Salami Sub

Thinly Sliced Salami with Provolone Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$10.31 +
Order B. L. T. food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
B. L. T.

Applewood Smoked Bacon Piled High over a bed of Lettuce & Tomato with Provolone Cheese.

$11.36 +
Order Tuna food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Tuna

Freshly made Tuna with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese

$10.69 +
Order Turkey Club food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Turkey Club

Our Amazing Turkey Sub with a Little Extra...BACON!!!

$12.74 +

TRADITIONAL PIZZA

Order Slice food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Slice

Gourmet Slice - Meat Eaters Pizza-available until 5:00 PM M-F

$5.56 +
Order Small Pizza food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Small Pizza

10" Pie cut in to 6 Slices

$12.36
Order Medium Pizza food online from John's Pizza & Subs store, Grand Island on bringmethat.com
Medium Pizza

Our 13" pizza cut in to 8 Slices

$18.24

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews