Old Mill Inn

5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952
Tuesday's hours: 11:00am - 9:00pm
Naked Cowboy Oysters on the Half Shell
$13.00
Little Neck Clams on the Half Shell
$10.00
Classic New England Clam Chowder
$8.00
Fried Calamari
$12.00
Fried Oysters
$13.00
Coconut Shrimp
$12.00
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
$12.00
Angry Mussels
$14.00
Pan Roasted Lump Crabcake
$14.00
Sesame Crusted Seared Sashimi Tuna
$13.00
Filet Mignon Spring Rolls
$11.00
Old Mill Caprese
$10.00
Organic Local Kale Salad
$11.00
Classic Iceberg Wedge
$9.00
Old Mill Salad
$11.00
Roasted Wild Mushrooms
$18.00
White Bean Puree
$18.00
Duck Confit
$20.00
Rustic Margherita
$16.00
Daily Selection of 3 Cheeses From the Village Cheese Shop
-
Fish and Chips
$18.00
Linguini & Clams
$22.00
Pan Seared Crispy Skin Salmon*
$24.00
Pan Seared Tuna Steak*
$28.00
Grilled Chicken Breast
$20.00
Steak Au Poivre*
$30.00
Long Island Duck Breast*
$30.00
Mattituck Lobster Roll
$22.00
Quinoa Burger
$11.00
Old Mill Burger
$12.00
Citrus Coleslaw
$4.00
Local Farmstand Vegetable
$6.00
Hand Cut Fries, Eggplant Fries
$5.00
Sweet Potato Wedges
$5.00
Naked Cowboy Oysters on the Half Shell
$13.00
Little Neck Clams on the Half Shell
$10.00
Classic New England Clam Chowder
$8.00
Fried Calamari
$12.00
Fried Oysters
$13.00
Coconut Shrimp
$12.00
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
$12.00
Angry Mussels
$14.00
Pan Roasted Lump Crabcake
$14.00
Sesame Crusted Seared Sashimi Tuna
$13.00
Filet Mignon Spring Rolls
$11.00
Old Mill Caprese
$10.00
Organic Local Kale Salad
$11.00
Classic Iceberg Wedge
$9.00
Old Mill Salad
$11.00
Roasted Wild Mushrooms
$18.00
White Bean Puree
$18.00
Duck Confit
$20.00
Rustic Margherita
$16.00
Daily Selection of 3 Cheeses From the Village Cheese Shop
-
Fish and Chips
$18.00
Oyster Po'boy
$14.00
Grilled Fish Tacos
$13.00
Mattituck Lobster Roll
$20.00
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$11.00
Quinoa Burger
$11.00
Shrimp Burger
$13.00
Salmon Burger
$13.00
Old Mill Burger*
$11.00
Grilled Steak Sandwich*
$14.00
Citrus Coleslaw
$4.00
Local Farmstand Vegetable
$6.00
Hand Cut Fries, Eggplant Fries
$5.00
Fried Sweet Potato Wedges
$5.00
Cava, Yá, Cuvée 23, NV, Spain
$9.00
Big Apple Wine, Wolffer Estates, '13, South Fork
$7.00
Sauv Blanc, Squealing Pig, '12 New Zealand
$12.00
Pinot Grigio, Ca' Donini, '10, Italy
$7.00
Pinot Blanc, Lieb, '09, North Fork
$12.00
Coalescence, Shinn Estates, '13, North Fork
$8.00
Chardonnay, Greg Norman, '11, California
$11.00
Rosé, Shinn Estates, '13, North Fork
$8.00
Pinot Noir, Hanging Vine, '11, California
$8.00
Merlot, Pelligrini, '07, North Fork
$7.00
Cabernet Franc, Bedell Cellars, '12, North Fork
$13.00
Malbec, Andeluna '10, Argentina
$9.00
Cava, Yá, Cuvée 23, NV Spain
$38.00
Brut, '07, Sparkling Pointe North Fork
$42.00
Brut Rosé, Scharffenberger California
$57.00
Big Apple Wine, Wölffer, '13 North Fork
$25.00
Coalescence, Shinn Estates '13 North Fork
$30.00
Pinot Blanc, Lieb, '09 North Fork
$43.00
Sauvingnon Blanc, Squealing Pig, '12 New Zealand
$48.00
Chardonnay, Greg Norman, '11 California
$39.00
Fiano Salento, Acante, Castello Monaci, '12 Italy
$38.00
Rosé, Shinn Estates, '13 North Fork
$34.00
Pinot Noir, Stadlmann, '12 Austria
$36.00
Merlot, Pelligrini, '07, North Fork
$26.00
Cabernet Franc, Bedell Cellars, '12, North Fork
$49.00
Malbec, Andeluna, '10 Argentina
$34.00
Cabernet Sauvignon, Beckmen, '10 California
$50.00
Musée, Bedell Cellars, '10 North Fork
$95.00
Southampton, Double White
$6.00
Blue Point, Toasted Lager
$6.00
Summer Shandy
$7.00
Estrella Dramm, Duara
$7.00
Bear Republic, Racer 5, IPA
$7.00
Budweiser & Bud Light
$5.00
Corona
$6.00
Coors Light
$5.00
Cider - Wölffer, 139, White & Rosé
$7.00
Heineken
$6.00
21st Ammendment, Brew Free or Die, IPA
$7.00
21st Ammendment, Hell or High Watermelon
$7.00
Magic Hat, #9
$7.00
Murphy's Stout (Lovelier than Guinness!)
$7.00
Southampton, Saison
$17.00
Lagunitas, Imperial Stout
$14.00
Ommegang, Abbey Ale - Doubel
$13.00
Cider - Aspall, Dry English Draft
$15.00
Mattituck Painkiller
$11.00
Dark and Stormy
$11.00
My Zombie Valentine
$10.00
Spotted Greyhound
$12.00
The Secret Garden
$12.00
Damn Bloody Mary
$10.00
Port, Tawny, Sandeman
$8.00
Port, 20 Yr Tawney, Cockburn
$11.00
Sambuca, Romano
$10.00
Tequila Reposado, Cabo Wabo
$12.00
Scotch, Oban
$12.00
Scotch, Glenfiddich
$12.00
Cognac, Martell
$10.00
Cognac, Courvoisier VS
$9.00
Cognac, Hennessy, VSOP, Privilege
$12.00
B & B
$10.00
Classic
$12.00
Cosmopolitan or Pomegranate
$13.00
French Gimlet
$13.00
Classic
$8.00
Lavender
$9.00
Classic
$8.00
Pomegranate
$10.00
Salty Chihuahua
$11.00
Classic
$9.00
Passion Fruit
$9.00
Island Breeze
$9.00
Root Beer - Boylan's
$4.00
Black Cherry - Boylan's
$4.00
Ginger Beer - Goslings
$4.00
House-made Lemonade
$4.00
Arnold Palmer
$4.00
Cola, Lemon Lime, Ginger Ale, Iced Tea
$3.00

Custom Item

Add Item

Order Details

We are currently closed right now and are unable to take any orders. Our hours of operations are Monday-Saturday 11am-11pm EST, Sunday 12pm-10pm EST.

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change


Browse Restaurants | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | FAQ | Restaurant Owners | Contact us

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Crunchbase AngelList Tumblr Instagram

© 2019 BringMeThat, Inc