Bring_me_that_logo

Nonnina - West Islip, NY

999 Montauk Hwy # West, West Islip, NY 11795
NY > West Islip > 11795
Pickup
|
Delivery






Dinner Menu

Antipasti / Starters

Order Veal Meatball Parmigiano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Veal Meatball Parmigiano

marinara, house-made mozzarella

Order Rhode Island Calamari Friti food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Rhode Island Calamari Friti

marinara picante

Order Ragout del Giorno food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Ragout del Giorno

over soft polenta

Order Clams Casino food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Clams Casino

bacon, garlic, roasted pepper, lemon butter

Order Octopus food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Octopus

cherry tomatoes, dill, red onion extra virgin olive oil, fresh lemon

Order PEI Mussels food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
PEI Mussels

white wine, garlic butter or orange-saffron butter

Order Shrimp Cocktail Salad Mexicano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Shrimp Cocktail Salad Mexicano

cilantro, cucumber, tomato, tortilla, jalapeno

Mozzarella di Bufala

Order Fire roasted red peppers food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Fire roasted red peppers

Order Roasted beets food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Roasted beets

Order Warm zucchini friti food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Warm zucchini friti

Tagliere / Boards

Order Parma Prosciutto Soprano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Parma Prosciutto Soprano

gran riserva

Order Formaggio food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Formaggio

house condimento Parmigiano Reggiano, manchego, tallegio, mahon, truffled moltenaro

Insalata

Order Chop food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Chop

salami, pecorino, peppers, cucumber, garbanzo, tomato, onion, taggiascca olives

Order Seafood food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Seafood

shrimp, scungilli, calamari, fennel, celery, red onion, lemon, EVOO

Order Tricolore food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Tricolore

crunchy molten brie cheese, beets, pistachios, pear mostarda vinaigrette, chorizo

Order Arugula food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Arugula

Medjool dates, gorgonzola, almonds, Hosu Asian pears

Pizza

Order Brooklyn food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Brooklyn

cheese on bottom, spicy sauce on top

Order Crispy Eggplant Parm food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Crispy Eggplant Parm

marinara, ricotta, mozzarella

Order Meatball food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Meatball

tomato, mozzarella

Order Margherita food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Margherita

tomato, basil, mozzarella

Order Bianca food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Bianca

ricotta, fontina, asparagus, truffle oil

Paste / Pasta

Order Ricotta Cavatelli food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Ricotta Cavatelli

bolognese

Order Rigatoni food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Rigatoni

sausage, cauliflower, garlic & oil, bread crumbs, piave cheese

Order Cheese Tortellini al Forno food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Cheese Tortellini al Forno

marinara, melted mozzarella & ricotta

Order Bucatini Amatriciana food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Bucatini Amatriciana

red onions. capicola bacon, marinara, bread crumbs

Order Whole Wheat Linguini food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Whole Wheat Linguini

grilled chicken, broccoli rabe, tomato, pecorino

Order Beef Short Rib Ravioli food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Beef Short Rib Ravioli

mascarpone finished tomato-mushroom gravy, locatelli

Piatti / Plates

Order Chicken Parmigiano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Chicken Parmigiano

san Marzano marinara, mozzarella

Order Big Shrimp Oreganata food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Big Shrimp Oreganata

cherry tomato faro, garlic lemon butter

Order Skirt Steak food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Skirt Steak

potato-mushroom-boursin cheese 'hash', fried onions, red wine sauce

Order Grilled Salmon food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Grilled Salmon

fall greens, pumpkin-poppy pieroigi, cranberry jam, spicy orange butter

Order Amish Organic Chicken Scarpariello food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Amish Organic Chicken Scarpariello

sausage, cherry pepper, potato, pan sauce

Order Prime N.Y Steak alla Fiorentina food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Prime N.Y Steak alla Fiorentina

crispy potatoes & broccoli rabe

Order L.I. Duck food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
L.I. Duck

breast & leg, parsnip puree, marsala-maple syrup poached Asian pear

Braciole di Vitello / Veal Chops

Order Grilled food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Grilled

sautéed spinach

Order Parmigiano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Parmigiano

san Marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella

Order Marsala food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Marsala

mixed mushroom - marsala pan gravy

Order Milanese food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Milanese

pounded, breaded & pan fried, arugula, mozzarella, & tomato salad

Order Saltimbocca food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Saltimbocca

prosciutto wrap, sherry-sage pan sauce, 'showering' of boiled egg

Contorni / Sides

Order Roasted Potatoes food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Roasted Potatoes

crispy garlic & shallots, showering of piave cheese

Order Mac & Cheese Italiano food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Mac & Cheese Italiano

cavatelli, bacon, fontina crema, truffle oil

Order Garlicky Greens food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Garlicky Greens

broccoli rabe or spinach

Dessert

Dolce

Order Tiramisu food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Tiramisu

Marscapone Creme, Espresso, Lady Fingers

Order Plate of Mini Cannoli food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Plate of Mini Cannoli

Pistachio Chocolate Dust

Order Semi Sweet Chocolate Mousse food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Semi Sweet Chocolate Mousse

Fresh Whipped Cream

Order Olive Oil Cake food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Olive Oil Cake

Marscapone Crème, Seasonal Fruit

Order New York Style Cheesecake food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
New York Style Cheesecake

Fresh Whipped Cream

Order Classic Crème Brulèe food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Classic Crème Brulèe

Creamy Custard, Caramelized Sugar

Order Biscotti Pignoli Plate food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Biscotti Pignoli Plate

Assorted Biscotti, Pignoli Cookies

Order Assorted Gelato & Sorbeto food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Assorted Gelato & Sorbeto

Sunday Family Style

Starters

Order Cold Antipasto food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Cold Antipasto

Buffalo Mozzarella, Salumi, Roasted Peppers, Olives, Caponata

Order House Salad food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
House Salad

Romaine, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Olives, Red Onion

Pasta

Order Ricotta Cavatelli Bolognese food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Ricotta Cavatelli Bolognese

House Made Cavatelli, Three Hour Braise of Veal Beef Pork

Order Rigatoni with Meatballs food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Rigatoni with Meatballs

House made veal meatballs, San Marzano Tomato Sauce

Order Manicotti food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Manicotti

Ricotta Filled Crepes, San Marzano Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella

Order Penne Ala Vodka food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Penne Ala Vodka

San Marzano Tomato, Hint of Prosciutto, Vodka, Cream

Meat & Fish

Order Shrimp Scampi food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Shrimp Scampi

Garlic, Lemon, Artichoke Hearts, Sardinian Couscous

Order Steak Pizzaiola food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Steak Pizzaiola

Sliced Steak with Peppers, Mushrooms, Tomato, Penne Pasta

Order Chicken Scarpariello food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Chicken Scarpariello

Semi-Boneless Chicken, Sausage, Potato, Sweet Vinegar Peppers

Order Nonna's Chicken Parm food online from Nonnina store, West Islip on bringmethat.com
Nonna's Chicken Parm

Tender Chicken Cutlets, San Marzano Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ