Bring_me_that_logo

Benny's Pizza - Milwaukee, WI

1102 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53215
WI > Milwaukee > 53215

Order from similar restaurants nearby

Online ordering is not available here. Order from one of these restaurants instead. This restaurant's menu is still below.

Pickup
|
Delivery






Popular Items

French Fries

$1.88
Pepperoni

$12.06
Sausage

$12.06
Cheeseburger

$4.38
Cheese Sticks

$4.38
Pizza Puff

$2.81
Cheese

$11.75
Hot Chicken Wings

$8.75

Main Menu

Salads

Chef Salads Vegetables

$5.69
Benny's Salads

ham & cheese.

$7.44
Chicken Breast Salad

$8.69

Pizzas

Cheese

$11.75
Sausage

$12.06
Mushroom

$12.06
Onion

$12.06
Pepperoni

$12.06
Olive (b Or G)

$12.06
Ground Beef

$12.06
Shrimp

$12.06
Hot Pepper

$12.06
Green Pepper

$12.06
Bacon

$12.06
1/2 Cheese

$12.06
Tomato

$12.06
Broccoli

$12.06
Spinach

$12.06

Dinners & Pastas

Chicken Parmigiana

baked in the oven. comes with a side order of mostaccioli.

$9.25
Chicken Dinner

comes with a side order of fries, coleslaw and garlic bread.

$9.25
Shrimp Dinner

comes with shrimp sauce, a side order of fries, coleslaw and garlic bread.

$10.31
21 Pc. Shrimp Basket

comes with shrimp sauce.

$4.88
Spaghetti Dinner

comes with garlic bread and grated parmigiana cheese.

$5.94
Mostaccioli Dinner

comes with garlic bread and grated parmigiana cheese.

$5.94
Lasagna Dinner

comes with garlic bread and grated parmigiana cheese

$9.25
Full Slab Bbq Rib Dinner

comes with a side order of fries, coleslaw and garlic bread.

$21.19
1/2 Slab Bbq Rib Dinner

comes with a side order of fries, coleslaw and garlic bread.

$13.69

Sandwiches

Italian Beef Sandwich

$5.25
Bbq Beef Sandwich

$5.94
Italian Sausage Sandwich

$5.00
Meatball Sandwich

$5.00

Sandwiches With Fries

Fish Sandwich

$4.38
Hamburger

$4.06
Cheeseburger

$4.38
Chicken Sandwich

$4.38
Chicken Breast Sandwich

$6.19
Chicken B. Parmigiana Sand

$6.81
Gyros

$4.94

Side Orders

Pizza By The Slice

$2.19
Hot Dog W/fries

$1.88
French Fries

$1.88
Onion Rings

$2.81
6 Pc. Nuggets

$2.19
9 Pc. Nuggets

$3.12
Cheese Sticks

$4.38
Breaded Mushrooms

$4.06
Pizza Puff

$2.81
Garlic Bread

$2.44
Pizza Bread

$2.81
Hot Chicken Wings

$8.75
Cheese Fries

$2.44

Custom Item

Add Item

Disclaimer: Prices and availability are subject to change

0 Items in Cart

© 2026 BringMeThat, Inc

Terms and conditions FAQ Order with AI Reviews